The hat is decent, but the fact that it's green makes it look very odd when you wear it with other cosmetics. You can change it to perhaps a dark team-colour to make it fit better with the other cosmetics.

Other than that, this hat looks pretty good. I wouldn't mind seeing this in the game.

helpful and constructive, keep it up <3

it's bad. and of course all-class

this looks good on some classes like spy or demoman and then you added the rest of the 7 classes and pretty much made it, uninteresting, not original and boring, i know you workshoppers want your cool self made but can you actually put out something good instead of this garbage?

Looks super neat! Only thing I dont like is that its all class so you'll see it on a lot of classes, it matches more of a sniper or spy loadout but that's just a minor nitpick. Looks great nonetheless!

Great if it's Halloween exclusive

I’m not reading that essay

I want this. It looks great.Want it as an unusual.

bro wrote a whole ass essay about a tf2 cosmetic

The next issue is the default colour. Green doesn’t go well with many other cosmetics. If you unboxed this hat, you would almost certainly have to paint it in order for it to suit your loadout. I’d recommend changing its default colour to either a team colour or a neutral colour like brown or grey, which can be incorporated into loadouts far more easily and without requiring additional purchases.

Finally, unlike the snaggletooth Stetson, the model of your cosmetic is not detailed enough to sell that its monster themed. The Stetson has a very obvious face with glowing red eyes and big teeth. It doesn’t help that the eye on your cosmetic is on an angle and not a traditionally round eye shape, and the teeth look more like part of a pattern on the band of the hat. You need to make both aspects stand out more (such as by making the eye round and maybe giving it a pupil, and making the teeth more monster like by being pointier, etc) in order to really sell the monster aspect.

Alright, if you want some more ‘constructive’ feedback, here you go

(https://wiki.teamfortress.com/wiki/Snaggletoothed_Stetson in case you don’t know what I’m talking about)

Your cosmetic is very similar both visibly and conceptually to the snaggletooth Stetson, a multiclass monster themed cowboy hat that already exists in game. The only thing that sets your cosmetic apart is that it is all class, but this may not be a good thing. The Stetson is wearable by Engineer, Pyro and Sniper, classes for whom cowboy hats fit particularly well. There is a reason why you don’t see cowboy hats on classes like spy, medic or heavy, because it doesn’t fit the personality or general look of the class. If you wanted to make your cosmetic all class, the best thing for you to do would be to change the style of hat to something like a top hat (which every class can wear as in the case of the gibus, etc), but even then it would likely be viewed as just another top hat cosmetic.

this is cool, can you put this on the home recker? thanks!

looks nothing like the snaggletooth stetson. great job on this! does the eye glow?

i am beginning to think this hat may in fact be a monster

pretty cool

please keep feedback constructive. none of these comments are particularly helpful

I missed y'all nonsense <3

didn't we already get monster hats already?

yeah this is just Snaggletooth Stetson and I didn't like that hat either

Snaggletooth Stetson but all class, green, and with lower texture quality

It looks quite good, but something teels me that most players wouldn't be so happy seeing it being added into the game