You're entitled to your opinion, of course! I think there is some actual puzzling in Shelf Life 1, mostly in figuring out how to get to buttons and how they shift the level, blocking/unblocking new areas. Whereas this puzzle ends on a nice note of everything being put back in place (inspired by the Sheep Soul Orb rooms). I'm proud of both library levels~

Loved this variant more than the other one, because it did contain actual puzzles and not just simple timing and platforming.