These folks aren't seeing the big picture brilliance behind this cosmetic. While this specific one is unfitting, it presents the idea of creating a holiday-themed version of an otherwise season-round cosmetic, therefore tricking Valve into adding Smissmas cosmetics that work for more then one month out of the year.

Still not sure why I'd wan to stick a big tube of goo onto my Pyro, but the idea it represents is genius.

I remember a top hat that was like this, but what does a barber have do with a pyromaniac who's at this point in a full on dream state?

too big and too gaudy

Doesn't fit pyro. The modelling is good though.