I think it would be cool if you could swap between the flavors, and they all do something different. For example:

Strawberry:
+25 health healed when thrown
+25% speed when eaten (10 seconds)
+50% eat time

Chocolate:
Fills rage meter 1/4 full
On full rage: Attacks minicrit and deal heavy knockback for 10 seconds (activated through reload key)
+20% sandwich recharge time
Taking over 100 damage during rage cancels rage.

Vodka:
+25% damage resistance for 10 seconds
Cannot be thrown
Cannot be overhealed for 10 seconds after eating.

Maybe you could switch with right click.

Originally posted by Digitic:

I think it would be cool if you could swap between the flavors, and they all do something different. For example:

Strawberry:
+25 health healed when thrown
+25% speed when eaten (10 seconds)
+50% eat time

Chocolate:
Fills rage meter 1/4 full
On full rage: Attacks minicrit and deal heavy knockback for 10 seconds (activated through reload key)
+20% sandwich recharge time
Taking over 100 damage during rage cancels rage.

Vodka:
+25% damage resistance for 10 seconds
Cannot be thrown
Cannot be overhealed for 10 seconds after eating.

great idea and u can have the neopolatain that has a bit of all 3

strawberry: mini-crits for 10 sec, but run slower. speed restores after crits run out
chocolate: run faster, but max health decreased by what ever percentage valve decides. cap on health and and speed increase gets removed when player interacts with medical cabinet in spawn
vodka: increase defense, decrease damage output to what ever percentage valve decides. cap on damage and and defense increase gets removed when player interacts with medical cabinet in spawn
neopolitan: force player to use melee and grant crits for 3 attacks, switch back to primary upon use of final melee attack

and yes, you can switch between the four~

Originally posted by Digitic:

Maybe you could switch with right click.

i think with r like the vacinator

Upon being eaten:
5 seconds of fire resitance
-10% speed

You all are aware that Valve decides on the stats, right?

And most the crap you guys are throwing out is a tad bit on the overpowered side.(Digitic)

And here's an idea.

Functions like norm sandvich, but if you're on fire, it melts and you receive 2 secs of fire immunity.

Originally posted by MBT Twilight Sparkle:

You all are aware that Valve decides on the stats, right?

And most the crap you guys are throwing out is a tad bit on the overpowered side.(Digitic)

And here's an idea.

Functions like norm sandvich, but if you're on fire, it melts and you receive 2 secs of fire immunity.

You just said Valve decides the stats. Yet you just said your own idea. I bet Valve actually decides based on what they think is good out of the ideas suggested.

+When eaten, immunity from fire will be given for 10 seconds.
-When eaten, damage will be decreased by 15%

That is my idea. And yes, I am talking about the whole thing, not the flavors.

Originally posted by MBT Twilight Sparkle:

You all are aware that Valve decides on the stats, right?

And most the crap you guys are throwing out is a tad bit on the overpowered side.(Digitic)

And here's an idea.

Functions like norm sandvich, but if you're on fire, it melts and you receive 2 secs of fire immunity.

dude really???

I like the fire resistance idea, but I still like the flavors idea a little more. I agree (upon reviewing) that my stats are slightly OP, but they're a good start. No matter what though, it's still a great idea. Valve, please add this! It's been WAY too long without a weapon update!

Stats:
Digitic Ideas [Strawberry]

Chocolate:
+20% Damage Bonus On All Weapons
Rage Meter Builds When Damaged By Anything
-10% Faster Movement Speed
+10% Bullet Vunerability
Rage Meter will recharge your Chocolate

Vodka:
+15% Damage Resistance For 10 seconds
Recharge for 10 Seconds After Meter is Empty
+10% Eat Time
Cannot be thrown

How about something like a freeze effekt (case "ice sandvich"):

(-) 10% slower move speed. (also if primary wep is deployed.)
(-) 25% slower weapon switch.
(+) Adds 50% resistance to fire damage.
(+) Immunity from afterburn.
(+) On hit: slows down enemy players. (more than Natascha)
(i) Kill turns victim to ice. (like Spy-cicle)
(i) Effects last for 15 seconds. (like Buffalo Steak Sandvich)

Howabout just a Buffalo Steak Sandvich reskin? That sounds logical.

Originally posted by Fireball411:

Howabout just a Buffalo Steak Sandvich reskin? That sounds logical.

Or just a reskin for the dalk bar or the normal sandvich. really this just needs to be a reskin.