Honestly I'm not a huge fan of the idea, but the execution doesn't seem bad (judging by the pics)

looks incredible on the scattergun would like to see it on the black box

This indeed looks better than version one. I think the seaweed wrap still needs work, but its getting better I'd say. Keep it up!

imagine how it would look on the holy mackerel

You. Me. Gas station.

Interesting idea but I think it's poorly done

I hear ya! Im working on a revised version right now! Hopefully I can make it look better lol

You might wanna go for complete rework, the Photoshop crystal algae and especially that embossed rice texture just do NOT look good

The yinyang does not look good, it's red color contrasts with the salmon-orange and the seaweed textures. It'd be a lot better if you got rid of it.