I've since found a 52nd dive toy and a 9th glowstick, but nothing changes. In fact, when you have 52 toys you don't get the secret apple juice ending. So for now, I'm going to leave the guide as is.

If you really want to find these extra ones, the dive toy is in the looping zigzag hallway in the shrimp area. Instead of going into the small hole, keep looping and you'll find it on the floor. The glowstick is also in the shrimp area on a random bench. I think it was near the free chum.

https://youtu.be/_VnhhBT-KHk

#1) This toy spawns immediately after finishing lap 1. It'll be on the metal cart near the vending machine.











#2) You'll see this when going through the women's locker room to find the valve. It's just before the purple glowstick.











#3) I'm going to do my best to explain the path to these next two.

• Immediately after finding the valve, continue forward through a zig-zagging path until you see a thin hole in the wall.
  
• Go through and take an immediate right, followed by an immediate left, and another immediate right.
  
• Follow the linear path to a large open room. Directly across from you is a small island with a tree on it. You need to bunny hop through the water as fast as you can to reach the island, as the water is filled with stingrays.
  
• The toy is inside the tree.

#4) From the previous toys location:

• Bunny hop back across the water to the entrance of the large room and follow the linear path until it deviates.
  
• Follow the right wall and you'll reach a gap you need to jump across. Do so, follow the path, then jump across again.
  
• After the bend, take the path on your right, then go through without deviating. At the end should be a staircase leading to the toy.

#5) After using the lever to drain the water in the women's locker room, you can find this in a locker in the middle of the room. You can grab this at any point you come in here (after your 4th lap), but it's easier to do so when the stingray is gone.











#6) Make sure you have chum before you go into the hole in the men's locker. If you don't have one now, you can still grab this after restoring power.
Once you drop down the hole in the men's bathroom, you'll be in a small room filled with water and piranhas. You should be able to just peak into a room across the way with the toy. Throw the chum into the water and book it across. Grab the toy, and book it back. You have to be very quick here.











#7) This one is right between you and the pipe puzzle in the water.











#8) Once again, work with me while I explain this one.

• Immediately after grabbing the fuse, fall down the hole and you'll be underwater with a bunch of lockers. Straight ahead will be a purple-lit cave. Don't go in there. Instead, facing that purple cave, look down and to the left to find another hole you can swim through.
  
• Follow the long hallway until you go down a slope and into an anglerfish den. As soon as you can, turn left and swim over the rock. Be very careful doing this. The angler on your right is extremely close, and it's very easy to get stuck on the rock. If you need to find another way, do so.
  
• Once you're over the rock, look to your left for another path you can go down. At the very end will be a massive angler and your toy!

#9) After completing the angler cave, you'll drop into a bathroom. As soon as you do, turn right, then left. Straight ahead will be a bottle of water and a candy bar. From their location, turn right and look inside the plant pot.











#10) On the ledge as soon as you reach the end of the water slide. Be careful not to slide too far!











#11) This one is sneaky and is hiding behind the white door at the end of the game.

There's 40 toys that can be collected while swimming in the pool. Their spawns are static, and the game checkpoints every 2 laps, so you can practice learning a good route to collect them all without sacrificing too much energy by getting killed to reset the checkpoint.


#1-5) Spawn on lap 2. They form a neat line up the right side of the pool.











#6-10) Lap 3 has a decent spread up the middle of the pool.











#11-15) Lap 4 goes up the middle again. It's best to start from the right corner, then work your way up.











#16-20) All of lap 5's toys are along the rocky dip in the middle of the pool. One of the toys is at the top, while the other 4 are below. 2 at the far ends, 1 in the middle, and the red is below the blue up top, tucked into a little rock. Very easy to miss.











#21-25) Lap 6 has a decent spread, but all of them are thankfully in plain sight.











#26-30) Here is where it's going to start getting hard to give you visual aid. Lap 7 has a decent spread, but they're mostly up the middle. The first one is directly under one of the diving platforms, one is on the rocky ledge just behind the hammerhead's fat head in the screenshot, 2 are in the deep end in the middle of the pool, and the red is hiding in a patch of grass with an anglerfish.











#31-35) The spread on this lap is kind of big. One will drop in the grass on the left side of where you can drop in, the 2nd will be in the middle of the deep end, a blue will spawn a bit further ahead from the 2nd toy tucked into a rock on the left, and a red will spawn to the right of the 2nd toy on top of a rock. Finally, the 5th toy is at the upper left corner of the shallow end.











#36-40) The last pool set is the easiest to explain, but some of the hardest to find. A toy will spawn on each corner of the pool, and the 5th one will spawn in the direct center. What makes this lap tough is the pool will get very dark, very fast, and it's easy to get disoriented while grabbing them or run into the hammerhead.

There are 8 glowsticks in the game. 4 come from the vending machine at 2 toys a piece, and the other 4 are found scattered throughout the side areas.

#1) Found just before entering the area with the shrimp in the women's bathroom. Pretty much impossible to miss.











#2) Found in the secret women's bathroom area with the tree. Refer to Toy #3 in the Non-Pool category to get there.











#3) Found inside a locker in the men's bathroom. I always grabbed it on my way to the fuse, but it might spawn earlier.











#4) After dropping down the hole in the men's bathroom, you'll be in a small room filled with water and piranhas. Inside the water will be a lit red glowstick. You need to use chum to lure the piranhas long enough for you to grab it and escape.