This achievement is a pain in the ass. Pure luck. It's a 1/5^5 (1/3,215) chance, 0.032%, or 0.00032. I fell asleep with an auto-clicker on (which selected the first 5 items, checked the combination, excited the level, and rinse-repeat) and woke up to the win screen, but God knows how many attempts it took. Similar story with "The Worlds Best Baker", but this is worse.

In short, if you're going to do this one manually, good luck.