Recettear: An Item Shop's Tale

Recettear: An Item Shop's Tale

Not enough ratings
Guide for Evaluating Fusion Recipe Ingredients
By petermax
Ever been stuck on floor 47 of a dungeon, with a full back, wondering whether you should drop a Knight's Sword or a Water Crystal for that Mystery Ring that just dropped? This guide is meant to help with that. Includes information meant for early game and late game, on items you might find during a dungeon crawl that are used in fusion recipes.
   
Award
Favorite
Favorited
Unfavorite
Overview
To get a couple things out of the way, I'm not going to be talking much about my process for evaluating items in this guide. I intend to make a second guide going into those details (along with some secondary conclusions) in the near future, but it ended up being a much more complicated process than I anticipated.

Since this is meant to be a quick reference guide, I've split it into two sections, one for early-game and one for late-game. The early-game table is focused on short-term profit, and only considers the first two tiers of fusions and items that are commonly available in the first few dungeons. The late-game table focuses on long-term profit, and includes information on how many of each common item are worth saving for when you find rarer items. Each is followed by a list of items which are worth holding on in limited quantities to to make valuable fusions with much rarer items. To give credit where it's due, I used the wiki as a reference for a lot of the information in this guide (backing it up with game data where appropriate). It's generally not an accurate reference for technical or in-depth information, but as a starting point or for very superficial information it does fine.

As for how to use this guide, the values given for each item can be thought of as replacing their base price in terms of how much you can make by selling them (after fusing them properly). For example, while Charred Lizards have a base price of 500 pix, by fusing them into Azure Necklaces you can make a net profit of 12,500 pix. This means that when emptying your bag in a dungeon, you should toss out Silver Helms (10,000 pix) before Charred Lizards, but should toss out Charred Lizards before tossing out Shell Necklaces (33,000 pix), unless of course you want them for other reasons, like encyclopedia completion.

The secondary lists will include some ingredients that are not normally profitable to collect that are worth holding onto some of for recipes using much rarer items. For example, you'll lose money collecting every Slime Fluid you see, but if you have ten of them in stock you can turn any Flytrap Bulbs you collect into Hallowed Charms, for a profit of about 4,000 pix. They also have some ingredients that are profitable on their own, but can attain even greater profit with rarer items. For example, Charred Lizards can be fused into Azure Necklaces for a total value of 12,500 pix, as mentioned above, but an Azure Necklace can be fused with Ghost Tears into Rune Amulets for an additional 15,240 pix of profit. While it's a good idea to sell most Azure Necklaces right away, it's worth holding on to a few to use up any Ghost Tears you might find.

Finally, there are some ingredients that will not appear on any lists- this is because they are not used in any profitable recipes, so fusing using them will always lose you money over selling them. Here's a list of these items, for completeness sake:

Ingredients: Chestnut, Powerful Antivenom, Broken Seal, Flint, Soft Stone, Tail, Large Fang, Wyvern Horn, Gold Horn*

Medicines: Ferromin L, Omega Ferromin

Food: Roast Chicken, Honey, Lobster

Treasures: Pot Stand, Music Box, Wind Emblem, Coin Emblem, Food Emblem, Miniature Castle

Equipment: Succubus Bow, Demongod Hand, Ak-kai Claw, Pandora Unit*, Perfect Shirt, Phoenix Garb, Santa Coat, Faust's Bargain, Plate of Grief, Devil's Will, Angel Bracelet, Nevan's Armband, Hevelius, Sealed Shield, Assassin's Hood, Asuran Helm, Ebon Talisman, Spirit Magatama, Heretic Necklace, Imperial Cape, Dracozombie Wing, Diana's Heart, Samael's Mantle, Trailblazers, Iron Sandals, Heavenly Heels, Soul Ring

Books: 200 Warriors

*These items can be productively fused, depending on how you evaluate Salamander Scales- see the notes section for details.
Tldr; How to Use This Guide
Go to the appropriate section (Early Game or Late Game).

Search for the name of the item you want to evaluate.

If it's in the first table, use the value given there.

If it's in the second table, look at how many you have in stock already- if it's within the given range, use the higher value, otherwise use the lower value.

If it isn't in either table, just use the base price.


Example 1:
You want to know the value of a Starsand Hourglass.

In the first table, you see find its row:
Starsand Hourglass
13,200 pix
17,467 pix
Holy Trident
1x Flameguard, 1x Candlestick

Use the value 17,467 pix.


Example 2:
An Eyebat King just dropped a Brave Heart, and you want to know if it's worth dropping a Chobham Armor (33,000 pix) for.

In the first table, you find its row:
Brave Heart
4,050 pix
17,100 pix
Platform Shoes
But you also find a row in the second table:
Brave Heart
17,100 pix
83,050 pix
<1
Soul Eater, Remetogen

You check and see that you have two in stock already, so you go with 17,100 pix (the first value in the second table, and the value in the first table), and decide not to drop the armor for it.

Example 3:
You have six Air Crystals in your inventory, and want to know if you should throw any of them out to pick up a Silver Helm (10,000 pix), a Silver Gauntlet (10,000 pix), or a Parade Armor (5,600 pix)

It has no row in the first table. In the second table you find three rows:
Air Crystal
2,700 pix
9,600 pix
23 to 25
Breaker Sword, Seafood Bowl
Air Crystal
2,700 pix
17,600 pix
3 to 22
Atou
Air Crystal
2,700 pix
17,667 pix
<3
Cupid's Bow

You check and see you have 21 Air Crystals in stock. The first two Air Crystals in your inventory are thus worth 17,600 pix each, the next three are worth 9,600, and the last is only worth 2,700. So you can profitably throw away three Air Crystals to pick up the three new items.
Early Game
Profitable to fuse and sell:
Item Name
Base Price
Value
Recipe
Other Required Items
Insect Trap
120 pix
390 pix
Maiden's Bracelet (Rank 1 Bracelet)
Slime Liver
1,800 pix
3,450 pix
Knight's Helm (Rank 1 Helm)
Broken Ring
5 pix
3,521 pix
Mystery Ring (Rank 2 Ring)
2x Gaseous Grass
Fin Fan
1,300 pix
3,800 pix
Survival Knife (Rank 1 Dagger)
Flytrap Bulb
450 pix
4,200 pix
Hallowed Charm (Rank 1 Charm)
10x Slime Fluid
Herb Seed
320 pix
5,100 pix
Rosewood Bow (Rank 1 Bow)
Gaseous Grass
270 pix
5,100 pix
Miracle Charm (Rank 2 Charm)
1x Eternal Ice
Red Oil
1,500 pix
5,867 pix
Plaid Muffler (Rank 1 Scarf)
8x Toothpick
Ghost Tear
2,620 pix
7,700 pix
Rune Amulet (Rank 2 Necklace)
1x Charred Lizard
Water Crystal
2,500 pix
8,200 pix
Mermaid Boots (Rank 1 Shoes)
Charred Lizard
500 pix
12,500 pix
Azure Necklace (Rank 1 Necklace)
Special Inkwell
600 pix
13,000 pix
Romantic's Cape (Rank 1 Cape)
Brave Heart
4,050 pix
17,100 pix
Platform Shoes (Rank 2 Shoes)
Earth Crystal
2,700 pix
2,3833 pix
Twisted Blade (Rank 2 Dagger)

Profitable to save:
Item Name
Base Price/Value
Profit-per-Item from Saving
Range Stored for Profit
Other Items for Recipe
Slime Fluid
100 pix
475 pix
<10
Flytrap Bulb
Toothpicks
300 pix
1,938 pix
<8
Red Oil
Eternal Ice
500 pix
24,650 pix
<1
Gaseous Grass
Charred Lizard
12,500 pix
27740 pix
<1
Ghost Tear
Gaseous Grass
5,100 pix
27,805 pix
<2
Broken Ring
Late Game
Profitable to fuse and sell:
Item Name
Base Price
Value
Recipe
Other Required Items
Insect Trap
120 pix
390 pix
Maiden's Bracelet
Water Shroom
170 pix
580 pix
Kid's Lunch
2x Shrimp Doria, 1x Mango Pudding
Coffee Beans
450 pix
1,550 pix
Buche-de-noel
5x Chocolate Bar, 10x Nut Mix
Shark Fin
2,000 pix
3,000 pix
Ultraburger
1x Cutlet Bowl, 4x Egg Toast
Slime Liver
1,800 pix
3,450 pix
Knight's Helm
Broken Ring
5 pix
3,521 pix
Mystery Ring
2x Gaseous Grass
Fin Fan
1,300 pix
3,800 pix
Survival Knife
Flytrap Bulb
450 pix
4,200 pix
Hallowed Charm
10x Slime Fluid
Herb Seed
320 pix
5,100 pix
Rosewood Bow
Gaseous Grass
270 pix
5,100 pix
Miracle Charm
1x Eternal Ice
Red Oil
1,500 pix
5,867 pix
Plaid Muffler
8x Toothpick
Fur Ball
110 pix
6,840 pix
Celebratory Wallpaper
2x Charred Lizard
Medicine Base*
500 pix
~7,500 pix
Concoction
1x Water/Fire/Air Crystal
Ghost Tear
2,620 pix
7,700 pix
Rune Amulet (Rank 2 Necklace)
1x Charred Lizard
Water Crystal
2,500 pix
8,200 pix
Mermaid Boots
Charred Lizard
500 pix
12,500 pix
Azure Necklace
Special Inkwell
600 pix
13,000 pix
Romantic's Cape
Slime Stone
3,600 pix
14,433 pix
Awakening Claw
10x Coffee Beans
Jellystone
4,400 pix
15,090 pix
Dream Kaleidoscope
5x Goldfish Bowl, 5x Insect Trap
Brave Heart
4,050 pix
17,100 pix
Platform Shoes
Starsand Hourglass
13,200 pix
17,467 pix
Holy Trident
1x Flameguard, 1x Candlestick
Seafood Bowl
14,600 pix
19,775 pix
Tuna Cutter
1x Breaker Sword, 3x Air Crystal
Flameguard
16,000 pix
20,267 pix
Holy Trident
1x Starsand Hourglass, 1x Candlestick
Earth Crystal
2,700 pix
2,3833 pix
Twisted Blade
Breaker Sword
14,000 pix
24,350 pix
Tuna Cutter
3x Air Crystal, 2x Seafood Bowl
Goldfish Bowl
15,900 pix
26,590 pix
Dream Kaleidoscope
5x Insect Trap, 5x Jellystone
Power Wrist
8,600 pix
28,440 pix
Sun Armband
2x Fire Crystal, 2x Natural Heater
Candlestick
38,000 pix
42,267 pix
Holy Trident
1x Flameguard, 1x Starsand Hourglass
Salamander Shield
13,900 pix
48,400 pix
Runic Defender
1x Insect King Shell
Champion Glove
27,000 pix
48,667 pix
Rocket Glove
10x Gunpowder, 5x Red Oil
Messy Scroll
38,000 pix
55,000 pix
Spirit Staff
2x Back Scratcher, 10x Bat Wing, 2x Poison Crystal
Armadillo Armor
21,000 pix
56,200 pix
Holy Armor
1x Tough Stone
Cupid's Bow
18,000 pix
62,900 pix
The Tellbow
3x Air Crystal
King-shell Chest
12,800 pix
72,000 pix
White Chestplate
5x Tough Shell
Null-parts
38,000 pix
82,350 pix
Crisis Cannon
3x Paralysis Crystal, 3x Big Screw
Ishtoril
68,800 pix
90,000 pix
Topknot Hat
5x Special Inkwell
Salamander Scale
700 pix
91,067 pix
Battle Suit
1x Guardian Armor, 1x Tough Stone
Goetia Robe
71,500 pix
103,200 pix
Wharf Coat
10x Natural Heater
Old Man Pole
82,000 pix
133,500 pix
Mortemirare
1x Lesato, 10x Paralysis Crystals
Mana Charm
82,000 pix
159,000 pix
Ancient Charm
1x Mystery Ring
Bassmaster Rod
148,000 pix
170,000 pix
Nature's Grace
1x Lesato, 10x Paralysis Crystal, 1x Abyssal Glaive
Lesato
138,000 pix
189,500 pix
Mortemirare
1x Old Man Pole, 10x Paralysis Crystal
Alleus
94,000 pix
208,400 pix
Siegebreaker Helm
3x Insect King Shell
Crystal Rod
52,000 pix
214,000 pix
True Crystal Rod
1x Starstone Staff, 5x Darkness Crystal
Arc Saber
120,000 pix
222,000 pix
Holy Sword
10x Fire Crystal
Soul Eater
200,000 pix
226,450 pix
Eraser Claw
1x Remetogen, 1x Brave Heart
Remetogen
200,000 pix
226,450 pix
Eraser Claw
1x Soul Eater, 1x Brave Heart
Dudely Mitts
113,200 pix
301,595 pix
A Man's Fist
5x Slime Stone, 1x Tough Stone
Atou
130,000 pix
279,000 pix
Ghostblade
10x Air Crystal
Starstone Staff
128,000 pix
290,000 pix
True Crystal Rod
1x Crystal Rod, 5x Darkness Crystal
Causmedia
132,000 pix
291,000 pix
Crescent Bow
10x Void Crystal
Belenite Plate
114,000 pix
296,300 pix
Barrier Plate
5x Fin Fan, 1x Insect King Plate
Messiah Unit
250,000 pix
345,000 pix
Chaos Unit
1x Secret Mix, 10x Paralysis Crystal
Necronomicon
745,000 pix
746,000 pix
Divine Staff
1x Starstone Staff, 1x Crystal Rod, 5x Darkness Crystal, 1x Earth Emblem
Abyssal Glaive
756,000 pix
778,000 pix
Nature's Grace
1x Lesato, 10x Paralysis Crystal, Bassmaster Pole
Nephilim Claw
744,000 pix
806,950 pix
Omnipotent Claw
1x Soul Eater, 1x Remetogen, 1x Brave Heart, 1x Black Horn
Cultist Dagger
642,000 pix
844,000 pix
Master's Dagger
1x Atou, 10x Air Crystal, 1x Water Emblem,
Bloodblade
714,000 pix
948,000 pix
Heaven's Blade
1x Arc Saber, 10x Fire Crystal, 1x Flame Emblem
Late Game, pt. 2
Profitable to save:
Item Name
Base Price/Value
Profit-per-Item from Saving
Range Stored for Profit
Other Items for Recipe
Slime Fluid
100 pix
475 pix
<10
Flytrap Bulb
Egg Toast
500 pix
750 pix
<4
Shark Fin, Cutlet Bowl
Nut Mix
1,000 pix
1,550 pix
<10
Chocolate Bar, Coffee Beans
Chocolate Bar
500 pix
1,600 pix
<5
Coffee Beans, Nut Mix
Toothpicks
300 pix
1,938 pix
<8
Plaid Muffler
Gunpowder
200 pix
2,367 pix
<10
Champion Glove, Red Oil
Bat Wing
1,500 pix
2,990 pix
<10
Back Scratcher, Messy Scroll, Poison Crystal
Natural Heater
880 pix
3,180 pix
2 to 11
Goetia Robe
Coffee Beans
1,550 pix
3,700 pix
<10
Slime Stone
Shrimp Doria
4,800 pix
6,850 pix
<2
Mango Pudding, Watershroom
Mango Pudding
4,800 pix
8,900 pix
<1
Shrimp Doria, Watershroom
Water Crystal
8,700 pix
9,500 pix
<1
Solid Concoction
Air Crystal
2,700 pix
9,600 pix
23 to 25
Breaker Sword, Seafood Bowl
Cutlet Bowl
8,800 pix
9,800 pix
<1
Egg Toast, Shark Fin
Paralysis Crystal
4,900 pix
10,300 pix
3 to 22
Lesato
Natural Heater
880 pix
10,800 pix
<10
Power Wrist, Fire Crystal
Earth Emblem
10,000 pix
11,000 pix
<1
Starstone Staff, Crystal Staff, Darkness Crystal, Necronomicon
Fire Crystal
2,000 pix
11,920 pix
20 to 21
Power Wrist, Natural Heater
Fire Crystal
2,000 pix
12,200 pix
<20
Arc Saber
Paralysis Crystal
4,900 pix
12,292 pix
<3
Null-parts, Big Screw
Poison Crystal
4,900 pix
12,350 pix
10 to 11
Back Scratcher, Bat Wing, Messy Scroll
Tough Shell
800 pix
12,640 pix
<5
King-shell Chest
Back Scratcher
1,600 pix
13,750 pix
<2
Bat Wing, Messy Scroll, Poison Crystal
Poison Crystal
4,900 pix
14,400 pix
<10
Messiah Unit, Secret Mix
Big Screw
7,650 pix
15,042 pix
<3
Null-parts, Paralysis Crystal
Special Inkwell
13,000 pix
17,240 pix
2 to 6
Ishtoril
Air Crystal
2,700 pix
17,600 pix
3 to 22
Atou
Air Crystal
2,700 pix
17,667 pix
<3
Cupid's Bow
Insect Trap
390 pix
21,770 pix
<5
Jellystone, Goldfish Bowl
Void Crystal
8,000 pix
23,900 pix
<10
Causmedia
Eternal Ice
500 pix
24,650 pix
<1
Miracle Charm
Charred Lizard
12,500 pix
27,740 pix
<1
Rune Amulet
Gaseous Grass
5,100 pix
27,805 pix
<2
Mystery Ring
Slime Stone
14,433 pix
29,620 pix
<5
Dudely Mitts, Tough Stone
Insect King Shell
3,200 pix
37,700 pix
Exactly 4
Salamander Shield
Fin Fan
3,800 pix
37,760 pix
<5
Belenite Plate, Insect King Shell
Tough Stone
4,800 pix
40,000 pix
Exactly 3
Armadillo Armor
Insect King Shell
3,200 pix
41,333 pix
1 to 3
Alleus
Special Inkwell
13,000 pix
46,650 pix
<2
Fur Ball
Darkness Crystal
8,000 pix
72,800 pix
<10
Starstone Staff, Crystal Rod
Black Horn
10,000 pix
72,950 pix
<1
Soul Eater, Remetogen, Brave Heart, Nephilim Claw
Tough Stone
4,800 pix
80,733 pix
Exactly 1
Dudely Mitts, Slime Stone
Brave Heart
17,100 pix
83,050 pix
<1
Soul Eater, Remetogen
Mystery Ring
46,000 pix
123,000 pix
<1
Mana Charm
Insect King Shell
3,200 pix
173,000 pix
<1
Belenite Plate, Fin Fan
Secret Mix
100,000 pix
195,000 pix
<1
Messiah Unit, Poison Crystal
Water Emblem
10,000 pix
212,000 pix
<1
Starstone Staff, Crystal Rod, Darkness Crystal, Necronomicon
Crystal Rod
214,000 pix
214,500 pix
<1
Starstone Staff, Darkness Crystal, Necronomicon
Soul Eater
226,450 pix
257,925 pix
<1
Remetogen, Nephilim Claw, Black Horn
Remetogen
226,450 pix
257,925 pix
<1
Soul Eater, Nephilim Claw, Black Horn
Tough Stone
4,800 pix
275,900 pix
<1
Guardian Armor, Salamander Scale
Arc Saber
222,000 pix
456,000 pix
<1
Fire Crystal, Bloodblade, Flame Emblem
Atou
130,000 pix
481,000 pix
<1
Air Crystal, Cultist Dagger, Water Emblem
Final Notes:
*Medicine Base is difficult to evaluate- It's technically best to use with Fire or Wind Crystals, but is rare enough that you're very likely to have better things to do with them. Sturdy Concoction is technically the best use for Water Crystals, so I would recommend using up spare Water Crystals with any Medicine Bases you find, only using Fire/Air Crystals if you have a truly alarming surplus.

There are a couple tricky things that come up when evaluating the items for the late game.

The first is the idea of saving items to fuse/sell until there's a price increase in effect. This doesn't turn out to matter all that much to the core question of this guide most of the time, but you can apply the following rules:

Halve the value of things that cannot have their price increased (e.g. Capes, non-precious-metal treasures)
Add to the value of any fusion product that can have its price increased half the total value of any ingredients that cannot have their price increased (e.g. Survival Knife, Made with Fin Fan, goes from a value of 5,200 pix to 5,850 pix).
Subtract from the value of any fusion product that can't have its price increased half the total value of any ingredients that can have their price increased (Out of profitable recipes, only affects Mermaid Shoes, Platform Shoes, Dream Kaleidoscope, and the Concoctions).
Then calculate values as normal, and finally, double them.

This turns out to have surprisingly few consequences. The value of most items ends up simply doubling. Here's a full list of all affected values that do not just double:

Item Name
Original Value
Adjusted Value
Notes
Water Crystal
8,200 pix
9,600 pix
New recipe is for Gilded Sword.
Cat Statue
7,600 pix
10,800 pix
New recipe is for Knight Armor.
Special Inkwell
13,000 pix
13,000 pix
Capes can't have value increases.
Champion Glove
48,667 pix
126,667 pix
In addition to the normal doubling, also adds value for the Red Oil that would otherwise be going to the not-doubled Plaid Muffler.
Brave Heart
17,100 pix
17,100 pix
Platform Shoes cannot have value increase.
Jellystone
15,090 pix
14,300 pix
Dream Kaleidoscope can't have value increase, loses additional value from the no-longer-increased Maiden's Bracelet.
Goldfish Bowl
26,590 pix
25,800 pix
Same as above.
Fur Ball
6,840 pix
6,840 pix
Celebratory Wallpaper can't have value increase.
Additionally, Sturdy Concoctions are no longer worth making (and the value of Speedy and Strong Concoctions is cut almost in half).

The second tricky thing is deciding on the value of Salamander Scales. Unlike most other 'rare' drops in the game, it's technically possible to gain arbitrarily many of them in a run without relying on random drops at all. It's therefore difficult to decide how to consider them in relation to other 'rare' items. Since it requires significant investment of both preparation and time to gather them, I've decided to consider them similar to other rare, endgame drops in terms of their value. This has the effect of making the Battle Suit recipe more valuable and, as a consequence, the Omega Cannon and TH Shield recipes less valuable. If you instead consider them a common drop, their value becomes their base 700 pix, and the Omega Cannon recipe becomes more profitable, though the TH Shield recipe still isn't due to requiring Earth Crystals that are better used elsewhere. The adjusted value of Pandora Units/Gold Horns is now 1,189,750 pix and 299,750 pix respectively.

Finally, there are a number of cases in the late game of items of similar rarity both being required in just a single recipe, for example Jellystones and Goldfish Bowls in the Dream Kaleidoscope recipe. In these cases, the optimal strategy is to give the value of the recipe to whichever ingredient you have least of, but since that's not easy to guess given their similar rarity I've defaulted to giving them each half the total value of the recipe. These cases are noted by having the relevant ingredients bolded, so if you find yourself with a dozen Jellyshrooms and two Goldfish Bowls for some reason you can take that into account.
1 Comments
Ribbo 31 May, 2024 @ 3:18pm 
wall of text crits you for 500, you die.