This guide is meant to follow along the story from the start of a new game. While playing, follow this to collect every collectible and mystery in the Abbey Grounds.

There are several different types of collectibles you will find exploring the Abbey grounds.
1 – Apothecary Vessels (6)
2 – Bones of the Dead (6)
3 – Caretaker’s Journal (12)
4 – Hiram Shaw’s Journal (12)
5 – Lilith’s Journal (12)
6 – Hunter’s Journal (12)
7 – Wanda’s Journal (8)
8 – Interrogation Records (6)
9 – Tarot Cards (22)
10 – Masterworks (16)
11 – Haven (15) *The names might be random, but this is what they were when I found them

Follow the guide for all of these plus all of the mysteries.

Do the Tutorial and then the first mission then go to bed, then go to the Forge.

Day 1 - Daytime

Hunter’s Journal #1 – Inside your room

Tarot Card #1 (The Star) - Inside the forge (back right side)

Tarot Card #2 (The Moon) - Inside the forge (back left side)

Caretaker’s Journal #1 – Very south side of chapel.

Tarot Card #3 (Strength) – Next to the above journal

*Make sure to pick up the Fire Rod here as well.

*Go left into the Grotto and underneath the small bridge is the Water Rod

Old Midnight Suns Mystery #1 – Go to the left of the grotto and you will find a statue. Pay respects
to unlock the first one needed here

Masterwork #1 (Heart’s Ease) – From the above statue, go to the river and go north to the crack to find this sitting on a rock.

Masterwork #2 (Allegory of the Transience of Life) – NW of the Yard on the middle road

Tarot Card #4 (The Sun) – Follow the road north of the Abbey and you will find a wall. The road leading north will eventually get to a dead end next to a small pond.

Masterwork #3 (Evening in the Woods) – On the south side of the small pond listed above.

Masterwork #4 (The Damsel and Orlando) – To the right of the Abbey on the very south of the map between the cliff (circle) and Hunter’s Folly

Tarot Card #5 (Temperance) – Go directly north of the above masterwork (parallel to the forge)

THAT IS EVERYTHING YOU CAN GET AT THIS TIME

Day 1 - Nighttime

Once you get to the nighttime you will get a mission to visit Agatha. Follow your dog to talk to Agatha and you will unlock your first blood seal which is a challenge.

*After the challenge, enter the cave and pickup the Moon Seal then place it on the alter to get your first word of power “OPEN”

Wanda’s Journal #1 – On an alter in the same room you place the Moon Seal

WHEN YOU LEAVE THE CAVE, YOU WILL AUTOMATICALLY END THE DAY

Day 2 – Daytime

You will talk to Dr Strange about the box you recovered. Then learn about training until you are told about your next mission.

Caretaker’s Journal #2 – On a desk to the right of Mission table.

Caretaker’s Journal #3 – Behind Mission table.

Now head out to the left of the Abbey and use OPEN to get through the door.

Apothecary Vessel #1 – On a alter on the right after entering the area.

Tarot Card #6 (Justice) – Behind Agatha’s Alter

Haven #1 (The Quiet Hill) – Go down the left path and find your first Haven.

Tarot Card #7 (Death) – Go to the very south (on a small peninsula) and you will find it .

Masterwork #5 (Moonlight on Mount Lafayette, New Hampshire) – On the south side of this area, you will see a road that makes a square. This will have a mini alter and this masterwork is leaning against a wall.

Hunter’s Journal #2 – Next to the alter

Wanda’s Journal #2 – On the alter

Tarot Card #8 (The Wheel of Fortune) – On the left side, north of the bridge you can’t cross yet.

Apothecary Vessel #2 – Head north through another door you can OPEN and get to the ferry ring. It is to the left of that.

Tarot Card #9 (The Hermit) – Near the above vessel on the left before the alter

*Go to the alter to take the Air Rod

Haven #2 (Babbling Brook) – Exit the area and head NW down the river to find this Haven.

*Go directly north of the abbey and you will find a ladder you can climb down. Use OPEN to find a Arcane Key

Haven #3 (The Deserted Ruins) – Head slightly to the right (down the road) to find the next Haven.

*Now head to the Hunter’s Folly and use OPEN on the crypt. Inside you will find the Earth Rod

Hunter’s Journal #3 – Go back towards the Abbey and look to the right and you will see another door to OPEN. Go down the first path to the right and you will find this next to a overturned cart.

Haven #4 (The Grassy Hilltop) – Very near the above journal.

*You will find an unknown grave mystery past here.

Wanda’s Journal #3 – It is directly on the “Dreamer’s Decent” marker on the map.

Hunter’s Journal #4 – To the left of the above journal nearby on the same road.

*Go to the very right-hand side (right of “Dreamers Descent” marker and at the end you will find a table with chairs and a tapestry. On the table is Handmade Hunter Doll as well as a recipe book.

Hiram Shaw’s Journal #1 – Go into the cave to next to the above doll and find this at the end.

*Go NW along the road and you will find a wooden bridge to cross. On the right at the top is Handmade Caretaker Doll

*Head east and use OPEN to get into the “Stone Terrace” area. Turn right to the bottom and you will find your old fort. Inside is Handmade Lilith Doll

Hunter’s Journal #5 – On the southern road, head west to near the end and you will find this amongst some broken wood piles. (As well as a recipe book)

Masterwork #6 (The Return of the Cattle) – On the other side of the structure, right next to the above journal.

Tarot Card #10 (The High Priestess) – Head NE along the very right side of the map, past the “Standing Stones” and about midway up the road, before the fork you will find this. (If you take the right fork to the end you will find another recipe book on a small alter)

Haven #5 (The Windy Glade) – Head straight NW from the above card to find this in the grassy area.

Hunter’s Journal #6 – Look to the left of the blood door and go underneath the bridge. On the other side you will find this on the ground.

*Head NW of the journal to find the second statue for Old Midnight Suns Mystery #2

Hiram Shaw’s Journal #2 – From the statue, head to the road the curves SW and you will find a cave. Go inside and you will find this inside.

*From there, head straight out and you can now go back to the mystery grave. Place the 3 dolls and the caretaker will show up and give you a chest and key to end this mystery.

YOU CAN NOW DO THE NEXT MISSION, BECAUSE YOU CAN’T DO AGATHA’S CRYPT YET

Day 2 – Nighttime

You will hang out with your teammates and talk to Agatha again.

Caretaker’s Journal #4 – After reading Wanda’s book and being told to go back to Agatha’s crypt, go to the back of the library to find this.

*Once you get done talking to Agatha at her crypt, go ahead and place all the Rods into their respective alters and you will get another Moon Seal

You will now be at a point where you can’t really do anything until you continue till level 8 because that is when you unlock your next ability REVEAL

When you do a general or story mission, you will advance the day to night and vice versa.
The general missions are infinite, so do 2 and then a story is a good mix. Once you get to level 8 you will open up the blood gate and go through the tunnel to the “Valley of the Winds”

Wanda’s Journal #4 – After placing the moon bowel, and before REVEAL the bridge, it is on a rock on the right.

*Pickup the recipe book to the left and REVEAL the bridge to open the way back.

Haven #6 (The Secluded Clearing) Head north down the road and cross the bridge. You will see the Haven slightly on the left for the Haven.

Interrogation Report #1 – Head down the north path and take the left fork to a clearing to find a book on the alter for this.

Masterwork #7 (The Glorification of the Royal Hungarian Saints) – Before entering the church on the right side, next to a cart.

*Head down the left fork and enter “Shaw’s Church” to start the mystery. Talk to Agatha about the backstory.
1 – Use OPEN on the door in the back

Hiram Shaw’s Journal #3 – Inside the study after OPEN the door.

Hiram Shaw’s Journal #4 – Inside the study after OPEN the door. On the other table.

2 – REVEAL the papers on the middle desk to learn more

3 – OPEN the door at the back of the study to get outside.

Hunter’s Journal #7 – On the left after OPEN the second door.

Hiram Shaw’s Journal #5 – To the right, under the wooden bridge

Tarot Card #11 (The Hierophant) – To the left of the above journal under the bridge in a cart

4 – Go to the magical barrier and you will say that Dr. Strange might know more.

Wanda’s Journal #5 – Go back to the front of the church and head north on the right path to see this on a barrel on the right.

Masterwork #8 (The Weeders) – At the very end of the north path past the above journal on a table.

5 – Go ahead a Fast Travel back the Abbey and talk to Dr Strange. You will take him to the barrier.

*You will not be able to progress this any further until after the story mission “The Bells Tolls…”

Interrogation Report #2 – Head east along the long road and use REVEAL to get across the bridge. Take the first fork on the left and in a circle next to a tree is this book.

Haven #7 (The Foggy Graveyard) - Right near the above report.

Tarot Card #12 (The Empress) – Go to the nearby graveyard and look to the left to find this behind a gravestone.

*The path behind and leading north has a recipe book

Head past the graveyard heading north. You can take the left fork but it leads to a dead end and the “Corrupt Well” mystery that you can’t do yet, so take the right path. You will be told you can’t do anything here until you get the next moon seal.

Hunter’s Journal #8 – Directly behind Agatha before the bridge leading to the dead end.

Haven #8 (The Ancient Passage) Right next to the above journal.

Wanda’s Journal #6 – Head south from the above Haven and you will find this on some rocks.

*Head south and take the left fork and you will find the 3rd statue for Old Midnight Suns Mystery #3. There is also a recipe book on a table nearby.

Tarot Card #13 (The Emperor) – Next to the recipe book on the left of the table.

Haven #9 (The Mysterious Hill) Now go back and take the north path leading all the way to very north of the map. Use OPEN and get to “Agatha’s Cottage” to find this.

Caretaker’s Journal #5 – Directly to the right of the above Haven

Caretaker’s Journal #6 – Inside the cottage, left of the fireplace. *Also a recipe book

Caretaker’s Journal #7 – Inside the cottage, right of the fireplace.

Caretaker’s Journal #8 – To the right of the cottage under an awning.

Tarot Card #14 (The World) – Directly next to the above journal.

*There is a recipe book on a table nearby and use REVEAL on the statue behind the house to reveal a Legendary Chest!

Wanda’s Journal #7 – Fast travel to the “Stone Terrace” and go down the left fork to find this about midway on the road.

*You can use REVEAL on the “Standing Stones” but we will come back when you have all of you powers.

Haven #10 (The Isolated Pillar) Fast travel to “Agatha’s Crypt” and go to the left side to REVEAL a bridge. Across you will find this

Tarot Card #15 (The Hanged Man) – Directly next to the above haven.

YOU HAVE NOW FOUND EVERYTHING YOU CAN GET

Continue playing until you get to the mission called "Sneaking Out" where you fight Fallen Wanda

Caretaker’s Journal #9 – After the main mission “Sneaking Out” the caretaker’s room will now be open, and you can go inside to find this.

Caretaker’s Journal #10 – On the desk in the same room.

Caretaker’s Journal #11 – On the desk to the right of the above journal in the same room.

*There is also a recipe book in her room as well.

*You should be level 12 at this point. You will talk to Dr Strange who gives you a means to remove the barrier next to Shaw’s church.

1 – Fast travel to Shaw’s Church and go inside the cave and inspect the bones for the last resting place of Hiram Shaw.

Hiram Shaw’s Journal #6 – In the cave, in the back

2 – Go back inside the church and inspect the drawings on the table.

3 – Agatha will tell you that she needs to study them and to wait till tomorrow night, so do a mission.

4 – Go to the left of the Abbey to the river and follow it north to the dead end and collect Soil #1

5 – Travel to the “Stone Terrace” and head to the left and find a small cave. In the back is Soil #2

6 – Head back to the entrance at “Stone Terrace” and head to the left to find another small cave. In the back is Soil #3. (For reference, on the map, it will be to the right of a purple chest)

7 – Head back and talk to Agatha and give her the soil.

8 – You are now told to find the hanging tree. From “Shaw’s Church” it is the circle on the map to the left and from “Agatha’s Cottage” it is to the south. Look for the circle on the map (next to a grey chest)

9 – Use REVEAL on the tree to get the moon bowel.

10 – Go NE to the “Everflowing Glade” and head down the bridge and to the left to use the bowel on the red door.

*This challenge is for level 12. Once you beat it you will unlock PURIFY. Use it to remove corruption.

*Go to the hanging tree (where you got the last moon seal) and head up the path to the north till you can PURIFY. This will reveal a bridge that leads to MOON SEAL FRAGMENT #1

*Now go past the graveyard and head down the path at the very north to the left and find a bridge you can REVEAL to find the “Corrupted Well”. Use PURIFY on it to get a purple chest.

Tarot Card #16 (The Lovers) – PURIFY the path leading west and head down the path. You will see a wall you can OPEN and inside is a small graveyard. This is on the left.

Lilith’s Journal #1 – Directly behind the above Tarot card.

Masterwork #9 (The Dream of Aeneas) – To the right of the blue chest in the same graveyard.

*Head up the log on the right side of the small graveyard and around till the end to find MOON SEAL FRAGMENT #2

Caretaker’s Journal #12 – Head on the west road and enter Lilith’s Garden to talk to Agatha about the next moon seal. Directly to the right of the statue on a bench. (COMPLETES SET)

Wanda’s Journal #8 – At the back of the garden next to a blue chest is this journal. (COMPLETES SET)

Haven #11 (The Weathered Overlook) Head outside and to the back of the garden to find this Haven.

Bones of the Dead #1 (Sarah Howe) – From the above Haven head east on the map a short distance to find this on the left of the garden.

Tarot Card #17 (The Chariot) – REVEAL the bridge leading north and right before the next Challenge door (you can’t open yet) is this tarot card.

Bones of the Dead #2 (Martha Richards) –Go back to the “Garden of Envy” fast travel and use the reference of 3 blue chests you can REVEAL to form a triangle. This one is north of the left blue chest.

Bones of the Dead #3 (Elizabeth Smith) –This one is right next to the north blue chest.

*From the north blue chest, head to the left and you will find a cave you can PURIFY to go inside. Use REVEAL on the statue in the water to reveal a legendary chest. Then head up the ramp on the left to the end to find MOON SEAL FRAGMENT #3.

Hunter’s Journal #9 – Head out of the cave and go slightly south to the right to find this next to a barrel.

Lilith’s Journal #2 – From the above journal continue south and right before a rock pile you can’t break yet is this journal.

*Return to Agatha in the library and she will send you to get a flower. Fast travel to Agatha’s cabin and collect the mystery flower. You can then collect your last MOON SEAL.

After getting BREAK go back to the garden and talk to Agatha.

Lilith’s Journal #3 – Right after using BREAK it is on the table on the left.

Lilith’s Journal #4 – Go down the ladder and it is on the left in the basement.

Lilith’s Journal #5 – On the right in same basement

Lilith’s Journal #6 – On the right in same basement past the above journal.

Lilith’s Journal #7 – Right next to the above journal on the next desk

*Examine the alter to end the Mystery and 2 LEGENDARY chests will appear.

*BREAK the back wall to reveal the last symbols needed for the “Standing Stones”

Masterwork #10 (The Flower Girl) – Now head back to the “Garden of Envy” and head to the north road to use BREAK on the rocks. Past them is this on the right.

Bones of the Dead #4 (Margaret Adams) –Head to the west road and use BREAK to enter the area. Go under the bridge and on the left you will find these bones.

Lilith’s Journal #8 – Go down the right fork and you will find this on the ground on the right, right before the statue.

Bones of the Dead #5 (Anne Stevens) –Right next to the above journal.

*Right behind the bones is the last statue for Old Midnight Suns Mystery #4. This will complete the mystery and make a Legendary chest appear at the 4 statues near the abbey.

Hunter’s Journal #10 – Now go down the left fork and right before the Haven will be this journal on the left.

Haven #12 (The Foggy Teeth) Right behind the above journal

Lilith’s Journal #9 – From the Haven, go down the right fork and find an EPIC chest. Behind that on the left is this journal.

Bones of the Dead #6 (May Richards) –On the right behind the EPIC chest. (COMPLETES SET)

Hiram Shaw’s Journal #7 – From the Haven, go down the forward fork to a dead end and find this on the rocks on the left.

Lilith’s Journal #10 – From the Haven, go down the left fork and find this next to some debris on the ground. *There is a recipe book to the right of it.

Masterwork #11 (Still Life with a Skull and a Writing Quill) – Directly behind the above journal.

Lilith’s Journal #11 – Now go back to the “Garden of Envy” and head south to use BREAK and enter the new area “Misty Moors” this will be right after the rocks you destroy on a table on the right.

Haven #13 (The Stoney Valley) On the road south on the left, impossible not to see.
*From the Haven turn around and to the north you will see a wall to BREAK. Behind it is the “Stone Pyramid” mystery.
1 – Inspect the pyramid.
2 – Use REVEAL and an EPIC chest will appear.
3 – Open it to end the mystery.

Hunter’s Journal #11 – From where the Haven was head to the right wall and you will find this on the ground.

Hiram Shaw’s Journal #8 – About 10 feet south of the above journal on a table.

Tarot Card #18 (The Devil) – Head directly over to the left wall to find this on a table.

*Head to the right road and back north to find a BREAK which is just a shortcut back to “Lilith’s Garden”

Tarot Card #19 (The Judgement) – Go to the left wall and follow it south to find a well and this floating there.

Hiram Shaw’s Journal #9 – To the right of the above tarot card on a table.

*You can use BREAK on the south wall which is a shortcut back out.

Masterwork #12 (Girl with Cherries) – Now fast travel to :Everflowing Glade” and head south. Turn right before the big rocks and you will a breakable wall for BREAK. Immediately behind the wall on the left on the ground is this.

Hiram Shaw’s Journal #10 – On a table on the right of the EPIC chest in the same area.

Interrogation Report #3 – Head south and BREAK the big rocks to enter the new area, “Gideon’s Cross”. Head to a short path on the right to find this on a stand.

Masterwork #13 (Schloss Milkel in Moonlight) – Directly south you will find a broken small building. This is inside that building on the right. *A recipe book is on the left.

Interrogation Report #4 – Head down the left path of the broken building and find this against the wall.

Lilith’s Journal #12 – Directly south of the above report against the left wall. (COMPELTES SET)

Haven #14 (The Damp Trail) Literally right next to the above journal.

Hunter’s Journal #12 – Head about 20 feet south on the road and it is on the right on a table. (COMPLETES SET)

Tarot Card #20 (The Fool) – Contiune south and you will find a tree alter. Inspect it and then use REVEAL to make a Rare chest appear. Directly behind the tree is the tarot card.

Masterwork #14 (Moonlight, Wood Island Light) – Backtrack a few feet to find a path leading to the Rare chest you made appear and this will be right next to it.

Interrogation Report #5 – Head south past the alter tree and find a small path to the right (about 15 feet) and find this on a block.

Interrogation Report #6 – From the above report, head north on the same trail and you will find a wall to BREAK. This is behind the wall on a block. (COMPLETES SET)

*Use BREAK on the south wall of the area for a shortcut back out.

Tarot Card #21 (The Magician) – If you use the shortcut you will be in “Dreamer’s Descent”. Go all the wall south following the road and you will find a dead end with a wall you can BREAK. Inside will be a small graveyard for “Disturbed Grave” mystery and this tarot card on a table.
1 – Inspect the grave
2 – Use REVEAL on the red circle to make some skeletal remains appear and pick it up.
3 – Place the remains in the grave
4 – This will make a LEGENDARY chest appear and end the mystery.

Tarot Card #22 (The Tower) – Now head on the road east and then south to find a dead end with a big rock to BREAK. Behind this rock is the next tarot card on a desk. (COMPELETES SET)

Haven #15 (The Secluded Depression) - Right behind the tarot card. (LAST ONE)

*Now fast travel to the Standing Stones. You will complete the standing stones mystery.
The order is random each playthrough so you will have to check the 3 sites to get the correct order.
1 – Church in the Abbey
2 – Agatha’s Cottage
3 – Lilith’s Garden (in the basement)
4 – Each correct order will make a LEGENDARY chest appear. Once you do all 3, the mystery ends.

Apothecary Vessel #3 – Fast travel to “Whispering Wood” on head to the south to find a wall to BREAK. Behind it is this on the ground in front of a slab.

*Head to the left and you will find a blue torch. Use REVEAL to find Faery Ring #1 and start the
“Faery Rings” mystery.

Apothecary Vessel #4 – Head to the left of the bridge on the road and you will find a bench and slab. This is on the bench

Masterwork #15 (Two Men Contemplating the Moon) – On the slab next to the above vessel.

Hiram Shaw’s Journal #11 – On the same slab as the masterwork.

*Use REVEAL on the bridge and cross it. Then REVEAL on the ring on the left for Faery Ring #2

Hiram Shaw’s Journal #12 – Continue to the end to find this on the left on a slab. (COMPLETES SET)

Masterwork #16 (Vanitas Still Lift) – Directly next to the above journal.

Apothecary Vessel #5 – To the right of the above masterwork in a basket.

Apothecary Vessel #6– Use PURIFY on the weeds and this at the end behind a Rare chest. (COMPLETES SET)

*Finally head back to the “Whispering Wood” and use REVEAL on the last Faery ring to get Faery Ring #3 which ends the mystery and reveals a LEGENDARY CHEST. I did it in this order because the chest appears here next to the fast travel point making it easy to get ti

*Make sure to go back to the 4 statues to reveal the LEGENDARY chest on the map. (It is SE of the Abbey)

Continue playing until you open the Meteor mystery. At some point in the game (it is random).

When you do a hangout, if you choose “Stargazing” this can randomly start.

1 – Fast travel to the “Misty Moors” and the satellite will be next to you. Simply interact with it to end the mystery.