Steam Community :: Guide :: All Decisions and Consequences

Store Page

Grand Theft Auto IV: The Complete Edition

All Discussions Screenshots Broadcasts Videos News Guides Reviews

Grand Theft Auto IV: The Complete Edition > Guides > Bartender's Guides

280 ratings

All Decisions and Consequences

By Bartender

Throughout Grand Theft Auto IV, Niko will encounter various choices that shape the outcome of the story. The following guide contains all choices in the story of GTA IV.

WARNING: MAJOR SPOILER ALERT!

The following guide contains spoilers for the entire game. If you do not wish for the entire story to be spoiled, please, do not read this guide. You have been warned.

Award

Created by

Bartender
Offline

Category: Characters, Gameplay Basics, Story or Lore

Languages: English

Posted

Updated

23 Jul, 2013 @ 5:26am

7 Oct, 2013 @ 8:13am

11,865	Unique Visitors
431	Current Favorites

Guide Index

Overview

Decision #1 - "Ivan the Not So Terrible"

Decision #2 - "Ruff Rider"

Decision #3 - "Holland Nights"

Decision #4 - "The Holland Play"

Decision #5 - "Blood Brothers"

Decision #6 - "That Special Someone"

Decision #7 - DEAL or REVENGE

Comments

Decision #1 - "Ivan the Not So Terrible"

MISSION: "IVAN THE NOT SO TERRIBLE"

You can either:
1. SAVE IVAN: If you spare Ivan's life, he'll reappear again as a Random Character.
2. KILL IVAN: Ivan will die, and not appear anymore in the game.

Decision #2 - "Ruff Rider"

MISSION: "RUFF RIDER"

You can either:
1. SPARE CHERISE: Cherise will live, and will appear later in the game on a random encounter mission
2. KILL CHERISE: Cherise will die, and not appear anymore in the game.

Decision #3 - "Holland Nights"

MISSION: "HOLLAND NIGHTS"

You can either:
1. SPARE CLARENCE: If you spare Clarence's life, he'll reappear again as a Random Character.
2. KILL CLARENCE: Clarence will die, and not appear anymore in the game.

Decision #4 - "The Holland Play"

MISSION: "THE HOLLAND PLAY"

You can either:
1. KILL PLAYBOY X: If you kill Playboy X, you'll get his penthouse as a reward for you to use as your own safehouse, and Claude Speeds outfit from GTA III will be available for you by using the wardrope in the penthouse. Dwayne Forge will also become your friend if you reply positively to his E-Mail after the mission.
2. KILL DWAYNE FORGE: If you kill Dwayne, you'll get a $25,000 reward, and Playboy X will never speak to Niko again.

Decision #5 - "Blood Brothers"

MISSION: "BLOOD BROTHERS"

You can either:
1. KILL DERRICK MCREARY: If you kill Derrick, make sure to call Francis before the execution to double the reward to $20,000. You'll also get the ability to get rid up to a 3 star wanted level by calling Francis. This ability will be disabled after the end of the game.
2. KILL FRANCIS MCREARY: If you kill Francis, you will not receive anything from Derrick. However, this choice will simplify the next mission, Undertaker, where you need to drive to the cemetery in Colony Island instead of Steinway.

Decision #6 - "That Special Someone"

MISSION: "THAT SPECIAL SOMEONE"

You can either:
1. SPARE DARKO: This decision will have no impact on the storyline. The dialogue with Roman and Florian after the mission will change depending on the choice made.
2. KILL DARKO: This decision will have no impact on the storyline. The dialogue with Roman and Florian after the mission will change depending on the choice made.

Decision #7 - DEAL or REVENGE

After the mission "One Last Thing", in which Niko is given the option to do the deal with Dimitri or kill him, two missions appear on the radar so Niko can decide what to do. Depending on the mission chosen, the ending (as a result, the last two missions) will be different.

CHOICE 1: DEAL
Should the player take the Deal, Niko will receive $250,000. However, Roman will die and Kate will leave you.

CHOICE 2: REVENGE
Should the player wish to take Revenge, Niko will be able to kill both Dimitri and Pegarino, however, Kate will die.

24 Comments

< >

I AM EVIL I AM EVIL NO CAP!!! 27 Jan, 2023 @ 6:04pm

based

JeeKnee 25 Jun, 2022 @ 4:09pm

homeboy chill out man it was 2008

Breadman 8 Jan, 2022 @ 8:01pm

Below me, a man is cringe

ჰ 26 Dec, 2021 @ 12:42pm

scum kate can smd anyday fuck her deserved drive by shooting by manz gigachad pegorino.prob was infertile since she didnt want sex even when i finessed her with my unlimited swag

RUSH2112 20 Oct, 2021 @ 1:17am

GTA 4 is a game meant to be dark, but thats what makes it so good. Songs, light moods, word choice, the city, all ties up the game super well. Im playing story mode again for like the 6 time, it is so soooo good. The only complaint i have is they could get some of the original songs back into the game that helped add to the theme, i know you can use user radio, but its just not the same. But the game is still fantastic. I always choose to kill Dmitri. After the game ends anyway you slice it, a it feels like a big hole as been ripped into you. This game is trully a masterpiece and in some ways the story is relatable.

seaque 18 May, 2021 @ 7:08am

one of the weak spots of GTA IV is the choice at the end. Kate's death literally means nothing. We don't know her, she's not even fun to meet.

ssharber1008 5 Apr, 2021 @ 10:16pm

I choose revenge to be able to do more things with Roman. Losing Kate is a little sad, however, losing Roman is much harder.

Kevin 7 Sep, 2020 @ 1:22pm

i seen both "end" to Decision #7 - DEAL or REVENGE---and its a "hard" choice to make......

Kevin 24 Aug, 2020 @ 3:21pm

so in mission 86---------either way you LOOSE KATE :(

Yoimiya 29 Dec, 2019 @ 6:59am

If you spare Ivan and found him later on the street, he will asking you to come with him. Help him and he'll give you $1,000. If you spare Cherise and you found her later on the street, she'll just asking for help about her new boyfriend, you get nothing as a reward.

< >