#1 - In Tilo's cell, on the bed that Tilo wakes up on at the very beginning of the game

#2 - At the iron bars, on top of the stone rubble in Tilo's cell.

#3 - On the well in the center of the courtyard.

#4 - At the top of the ruined tower above smithy.

#5 - Outside the window above small enclosed area with broken canon.

#6 - On the window above a chest and a book stand.

#7 - Carrot garden, northwest corner between staircase entrance that leads to the Courtyard and a door that connects garden with Armoury Staircase.

#8 - At the beginning of stairs that lead down to Gusto and Fatale's cell.

#9 - On the ramparts next to the door that leads to Far Tower.

#10 - Next to the door below where the ramparts guard patrols.

#11 - As you pass through the doors that connect courtyard ramparts with the Far Tower, turn right and up the stairs to the small cot with a bed. The rose is just outside cot doors.

#12 - On top of the stairs leading to the large gates of the Clarion tower ruins.

#13 - Inside the Clarion tower ruins, on the ruined staircase. NOTE: This location is accessible only after you discover who "The Master" is.

#14 - On the arches by the stairs at the start of the location.

#15 - On the ruined arches overlooking the sea.

#16 - On the ruined arches close by the barrel you can save in.

#17 - On the walls of the large chapel with a worm inside.