edgys are meh about artys

artys are Meh about hipsters

Coming out to Vintage as sporty gets me a neutral reaction

Also worth noting: You can't come out to someone who currently has a problem. They'll ask to talk about it another time, but then you'll be locked out from re-selecting that person when you try to come out again.

coming out as chic to vintage doesn't go well

coming out as geeky to a hipster type seems to be having a neutral result rather than a positive one.

I think the game randomly assigns a inner type to non-imported villagers later in the game. I had 2 friends who were both Chic and who both ended up having Edgy secret inner types (let's call them friend Bill and Jill). When I found out Jill's inner type was Edgy, I had her come out to Bill even though I didn't know his inner type at the time. He hated it. Later, when Bill revealed his secret Edgy inner type, I had him successfully come out to Jill.

Now if the characters were imported from KP:MM then their inner type will be determined by what their guilty pleasures were in that game so if you had an Edgy individual whose guilty pleasure was interest rates, then you should be able to have a friend with a secret Chic inner type successfully come out to them even if haven't told you what their secret inner type is in KP:LL.

Granted this may be a one-off glitch, so unless we hear from the developer or more people test it out, we won't know for sure

@fraser.buchanan thank you!

Also worth noting: When "coming out", the game also takes into account the inner type of the friend you are coming out to and goes with whichever one is more favourable.

ie\ If you reveal a secret Edgy side to a Vintage Friend who has a secret Geeky side, then you'll be able to come out successfully. I believe this is true even if your Vintage friend's secret inner type is currently unknown.