i like the ufo ending cuz you get the best gun in the game with infinite ammo

I agree about Homecoming. Seems they were more interested in "fixing the combat" than paying attention to the mythology.

To me Silent Hill 1 and 2 are the best, followed by 3. Although part 3 plays very much like a remake of part 1, and the biggest flaw of the game is the biggest location, Brookhaven Hospital which just seemed to be copypasted from part 2 and felt completely random and redundant ;)

Would be cool if devs actually understood the story before friggin creating this piece of garbage, just too much BS in Homecomming plotline.

For me the best silent hill is SH3 , SH2 is amazing aswell and Downpour was surprisingly good if we ignore the stupid combat system.

Kanade; I agree. Everyone loves Pyramid Head, but no one realizes that he was just a figment of James' imagination. He even flat out states this at the ending of the game..
However Homecoming is not the worst SH game, that honor goes to SH 4: The Room and SH 0rigins

Lol, "plot holes"...

This game is one fucking huge plot hole, like for example Pyramid Head being in this game, James only related monster being in this stupid ass game.

Worst silent hill game in history.

All of these endings except for the Good ending create giant plotholes when you think about it...
Also, this is the only game in the entire franchise where you can accidentally get the joke ending(s) on your first playthrough, which IMHO is complete fail.

Me to

I Have Hospital ending , i go for the other 4

Silent Hill de Groaza

doesn't matter.