Recent reviews by Eddoink

Good:
-Best controls so far
-Best combat system so far (it's amazing!!)
-Bosses have consistent high quality
-Story is interesting and characters are really cool
-Very colourful by FromSoft's standards (which I like)
-Feels more open than older games (not fully open world or nothing but still nice)
-Music plays outside of boss battles
-Very streamlined (no potential levelling trouble, tutorial guy etc)
-Prosthetic tools are very reminiscent of zelda tools
-Finally a difficult final boss!!
-Eavesdropping is sick

Bad:
-Maybe a bit short
-Not crazy replayable
-Overworld music can get annoying
-Boss music isn't very memorable (it is nice to listen to though)
-Story is more like a zelda than a dark souls, it's not that cryptic (but I dont hate that)
-No weapon variety (some people hate this, I dont though)
-No different outfits (made me a little sad)
-Some areas don't feel like they were used enough or were very small / linear (abandoned dungeon, poison swamp)
-Some areas are reused (outskirts like 3 times!!)
-Dragonrot is SO easy to bypass (it's so not that bad, doesnt even kill NPCs)
-Some of the prosthetic weapons are SO irrelevant youll never use them
-Terror is mental

Overall:

I really do still recommend this game to Dark souls fans, maybe more so Bloodborne fans, and definitely new people looking to play a souls game. Definitely start with this one as it is the most streamlined and probably the shortest :)

9/10

Actually just so good