I dont understand the hate the gets from everywhere. Yes, it has outdated graphics, but it is only an AA game, so it is understandable. Some of the environment is but beautiful. Sound and music is good, VO is a bit odd, but nothing really bad. The game consist of stealthy gameplay, no fightings, it is Gollum we play for - so no wonder here.
I would reccomend the game to Lords of the Rings fans and people who like nice stories. Btw the technical side of the game is not a problem on my PC - some stutterings form time to time, but not gamebreaking.