Like most Telltale games, your choice doesn't really matter that much. But it didn't stop me from enjoying the game.

The story is just as good as other Telltale games. The characters and the humor really fit the Borderlands atmosphere. However, it is the cinematic intro of each episode that leave a mark for me. The intro music is so impeccable! I don't remember any other games where I said to myself during opening intro "Holy crap! This intro is so good" and make me look forward for the intro of the next episode.

No wonder they say that this is (arguably) the best Telltale game ever.