update:
It's a straight downgrade. Ranching balance has been totally broken, many elements are now locked behind a collectable grind. all QoL from travel has been removed.

none of the issues from the first game are addressed either.

I really really wish this was just a DLC map for the first game because the one good thing is exploration, but sadly that just can't carry this.

major balance pass is required to make this fun. if the dev reads this feel free to reach out and I'll give you lots and lots of detail.


Original review:
it's DLC.

the gameplay and game design are identical to the first game, just a new map.

if you go into it thinking of it as DLC, you'll be happy. If you're expecting a new game, you will be as disappointed as I am.

update: It's a straight downgrade. Ranching balance has been totally broken, many elements are now locked behind a collectable grind. all QoL from travel has been removed. none of the issues from the first game are addressed either. I really really wish this was just a DLC map for the first game because the one good thing is exploration, but sadly that just can't carry this. major balance pass is required to make this fun. if the dev reads this feel free to reach out and I'll give you lots and lots of detail. Original review: it's DLC. the gameplay and game design are identical to the first game, just a new map. if you go into it thinking of it as DLC, you'll be happy. If you're expecting a new game, you will be as disappointed as I am.