Best of 2023
- The Last of Us Part I (PC release)
- Lil Gator Game
- Dave The Diver
- Dredge
- Chants of Sennaar
- Sludge Life 2
- The Golden Idol DLC: The Spider of Lanka

Best of 2022
- Betrayal At Club Low (GOTY)
- The Case of the Golden Idol
- Return to Monkey Island
- NORCO
- Stray
- Immortality

Best of 2021
- Inscryption
- Outer Wilds Echoes of the Eye DLC
- Road 96
- Sable
- Hitman 3
- 12 Minutes
- Forza Horizon 5
- The Eternal Cylinder
- Gamedec

Best of 2020
- Cloudpunk
- Fall Guys
- Sludge Life
- Journey To The Savage Planet
- Desperados 3
- Superhot: Mind Control Delete
- Cyberpunk 2077
- Tell Me Why
- Not For Broadcast
- Watch Dogs: Legion
- Assemble with Care
- Procession To Calvary
- Tales from Off-Peak City Vol. 1
- Spiritfarer

Best of 2019
1. Outer Wilds [GOTY]
2. A Short Hike
3. Baba is You
4. Control
5. Red Dead Redemption 2
6. A Plague Tale: Innocence
7. Hypnospace Outlaw
8. Observation
9. What The Golf?
10. Superliminal

Best of 2018
1. Assassin's Creed Odyssey [GOTY]
2. Hitman 2
3. Forza Horizon 4
4. Life Is Strange 2
5. Do Not Feed The Monkeys
6. Donut Country
7. Minit
8. Not Tonight
9. Tetris Effect

Best of 2017
1. Thimbleweed Park [GOTY]
2. Life Is Strange: Before The Storm
3. Paradigm
4. Four Last Things
5. The Sexy Brutale
6. Beat Cop
7. What Remains Of Edith Finch
8. Pinball FX3
9. Echo
10. Tacoma

Best of 2016
1. Firewatch [GOTY]
2. Hitman
3. Oxenfree
4. Watch Dogs 2
5. Shadow Tactics: Blades Of The Shogun
6. Superhot
7. Unravel
8. Dishonored 2
9. Kathy Rain
10. Obduction

Best of 2015
1. else Heart.Break() [GOTY]
2. Life Is Strange
3. The Beginner's Guide
4. Her Story
5. Invisible, Inc.
6. Aviary Attorney
7. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
8. Cibele
9. Off-Peak
10. Just Cause 3

Best of 2013
1. Save The Date [GOTY]
2. The Stanley Parable
3. BioShock Infinite
4. Gone Home
5. The Last of Us
6. Papers, Please
7. Grand Theft Auto V
8. Kentucky Route Zero

Best of 2012
1. Counterfeit Monkey [GOTY]
2. XCOM: Enemy Unknown
3. Fez
4. Journey
5. The Pinball Arcade

2019 not played yet:
- Telling Lies
- Whispers of a Machine
- Eliza
- Disco Elysium
- Mutazione
- The Occupation

2020 not played yet:
- The Pedestrian
- Twin Mirror
- Call Of The Sea
- AC: Valhalla
- Firmament
- Beyond a Steel Sky
- Empire of Sin

2021 not played yet:
- Toem
- Life is Strange: True Colors
- Unpacking
- Maquette
- Where Cards Fall
- Last Stop