score and soundtrack are basically perfect (listen to thats the way it is and unshaken again if u dont agree :D), arthur's journey is really well paced and thematically strong and really glad that so many people seem to share this view as well because while the story isn't perfect (chapter 5 is a pointless addition) it's a resounding success for Rockstar and i think they kinda need it considering that they got gta6 leaked by a guy who was likely born after they started developing it and abandoned rdr2s online (and they won the labor of love award STILL)

speaking of, strongly recommend this game for the story but i really do mean just the story alone because rdo is cancer. even then though, valve will still dickride rockstar to the point that theyll give rdr2 the labor of love award despite online being abandoned for more than 2 years, like wtf

9/10, must play for anyone let alone gamers but obviously avoid online