Are these rules ok for everyone? For Unbundled Games Humble Bundle Monthly GA's points are worth half their value and GA's under 10points are divided in half.

Also what do you think about having unbundled game to have atleast Mostly Positive reviews?

And suggestions are welcome! :]

What do you think about getting rid of ratio in unbundled GA's?

Either members could freely do and enter those or there would be some do at least one GA per month etc? Because i think almost all people will end up with huge ratios in bundled GA's :D

Or should we get rid of ratio all together? And act as friendly group that does GA's? :D

Some answers would be nice :]

i think we should get rid of it. firstly as you say this is friendly group we dont need to push people by a ratio thing, secondly for now NZTi! is small group and if we put this ratio thing members wont enter all giveaways and maybe the most giveaways dont get at 5 entry.

Publicado originalmente por SpYsiDER™:

i think we should get rid of it. firstly as you say this is friendly group we dont need to push people by a ratio thing, secondly for now NZTi! is small group and if we put this ratio thing members wont enter all giveaways and maybe the most giveaways dont get at 5 entry.

Well we have always had some kind of ratio and worked fine as small group too. But i know the incentive to get rid of it completely.

If there are many differing opinions then i will do an poll about it.

Also when you post here tell me which kind of system would be best :]

We could do with system in place with some modifications or change it all together to something else. We could also add some starting points for members that are registered right now. Or do something like one GA per month thing. Rid of it all. Or just keep the themed group system :]

I think after we have had some conversation about how we like to shape this thing and have few good alternatives we should do an poll about it to get democratic decision.

There are GA's done right now and i think we should cancel them until we get this thing sorted out or atleast wait a few days to see what kind of answers we get.

And again. And if you want to be part of themed section check out the rules and enter here

And please subscribe to this thread and just to remind you that there are sub discussion forums :p

And sorry about the mass listing your pages, it was meant to be chat message, not post to page and i did not mean to send messages to former SGP members either, too sleepy :\

If you decide to keep the ratio system, I'd like clarification on the last rule, "GA's under 10points are divided in half" because someone can spend as much, or even more, buying multiple games for giveaway. I think if you keep ratio, and you're using the SG system as law to determine what's classified as bundled and how many points a game is worth, then stick with that. Halving points doesn't seem right because SG has already accounted for bundled and lower retail value games by assigning them a lower point value. I'm in favor of doing what it takes to encourage people to create and enter giveaways. Not finding any giveaways to enter and not getting 5 entries are my biggest issues with groups like this. That's my two cents. ;)

The rules seem okay to me.

Publicado originalmente por LadyOberon:

Not finding any giveaways to enter and not getting 5 entries are my biggest issues with groups like this. That's my two cents. ;)

I agree with LadyOberon that this is often the biggest issue with smaller giveaway groups in my experience too.

Publicado originalmente por DARKKi:

Publicado originalmente por SpYsiDER™:

i think we should get rid of it. firstly as you say this is friendly group we dont need to push people by a ratio thing, secondly for now NZTi! is small group and if we put this ratio thing members wont enter all giveaways and maybe the most giveaways dont get at 5 entry.

Well we have always had some kind of ratio and worked fine as small group too. But i know the incentive to get rid of it completely.

If there are many differing opinions then i will do an poll about it.

Also when you post here tell me which kind of system would be best :]

We could do with system in place with some modifications or change it all together to something else. We could also add some starting points for members that are registered right now. Or do something like one GA per month thing. Rid of it all. Or just keep the themed group system :]

I think after we have had some conversation about how we like to shape this thing and have few good alternatives we should do an poll about it to get democratic decision.

There are GA's done right now and i think we should cancel them until we get this thing sorted out or atleast wait a few days to see what kind of answers we get.

And again. And if you want to be part of themed section check out the rules and enter here

And please subscribe to this thread and just to remind you that there are sub discussion forums :p

And sorry about the mass listing your pages, it was meant to be chat message, not post to page and i did not mean to send messages to former SGP members either, too sleepy :\

i know we need some rules. maybe i get this ratio thing wrongly. i think we specify a limit 3 or 4 giveaway or 20p per month but we dont heed at winning side. cause if we plan to make unbundled and also themed unbundled giveaways, i think this will effect ratio system.

That's good to me. Will we still have also mandatory monthly themed GAs?

Rules are ok :)

- Mandatory monthly themed GA rule for all members, else we dont need this extra rule and could get rid of it. dont like mixed things.

- Also some kind of ratio is a good idea, but it shouldn´t force members into reconsidering wether to enter a GA or not. We all need 5 entries ^^! I´d like a "bring the points back system"
(won 3 GAs worth 30P and can now create, for example, two GAs worth 15P to stay clean,
+ mandatory GA )

- btw unbundled games only, bundled games are freebies and are extra topping for fun.

in my opinion

mandatory themed ga per month

the other ones always unbundled.

i don't like ratios i prfer to offer good games that nobody have but if you want one:
3 wins implies 1 mandatory ga. this ga must have 10 points minimum and humble counts halp points.

regards

i have read and subscribed

Okay, thanks for the input so far!

Remember that the Themed section does not affect by these rules in any way.

I will create an poll soon and post it in here to see what kind of responses we get.

Also i personally think that we let go of bundled ones and tag the bundled area as "Extra Giveaways" but i will address that in the poll as well.

Perfect situation would be that everyone in the group would be in Themed one and there would be an area for additional GA's but that is an hard sell. I will also add that into the poll :]

Lets stick to the current rules until then if there is not some overwhelming support for some idea.

When will the first themed giveaway go up so i know what yo pick up?