93/100-GameSpot
Looks and sounds great, it's exciting, it's suitably bug-free, and, at a time when eight hours is becoming the standard length for single-player shooters, it's long. Quite simply, Mafia is one of the best games of the year.
92/100-IGN
Mafia is dripping with style and class and has certainly shoved itself into the ranks of the best games of this year.
91/100-GameSpy
A game hasn't oozed this much style since the release of "Max Payne." The gameplay, the story, the graphics -- the entire presentation is topnotch.

http://www.mafia2game.com