Diposting pertama kali oleh Rade66:

Phantom: Requim for the Phantom? I don't think it fits clue 4, but it fits the first 3 almost exactly.

correct
and for clue 4 he buys and gives Cal Devens the pocket watch she was looking at

this might give it away

4. MC gives the girl living with him a pocket watch and she later becomes an assassin

Diposting pertama kali oleh Rade66:

I feel like this could fit a handful of things, but, I'l throw in Darker Than Black.

lol didnt think it would fit a lot but there are plenty of animes i havent seen yet either
nope

Diposting pertama kali oleh Justabit_Ginger:

Akame ga kill?

nope

only thing i can think of right now

1. MCs memories have been erased
2. story is about assassins
3. one of these assassins is basically a puppet due to her training and losing her memories

is it Baccano!

Diposting pertama kali oleh Drevas(alfa):

Diposting pertama kali oleh Cirno #TeamNepNep:

1. The anime deals with supernatural creatures
2. Male lead is immortal
3. Each episode has a colour in the name

could it be from Monogatari Series?

only thing that comes to mind here as well

Diposting pertama kali oleh Rade66:

Diposting pertama kali oleh Zeiram:

1. MC is famous for creating a cartoon dog character
2. people throughout the series get attacked by someone with a bat
3. the detectives investigating these crimes get fired

Paranoia Agent

correct your turn

1. MC is famous for creating a cartoon dog character
2. people throughout the series get attacked by someone with a bat
3. the detectives investigating these crimes get fired

Diposting pertama kali oleh Prince of Liechtenstein:

1. Takes place in the future
2. World is run by an intelligent system
3. Story is about the police force

Psycho Pass?