Soma
Amnesia (series)
Phasmophobia
Cosmodread

Evil Within
Dead Space
Zombie Army
The Walking Dead
State of Decay

Alien: Isolation
Blair Witch
Clock Tower: Rewind (the origin of the “stalker horror” genre)
Fatal Frame: Mask of the Lunar Eclipse
Hellblade: Senua’s Sacrifice
Killer Frequency
Remothered: Tormented Fathers
Resident Evil 4 (I’ve only played the original, I’m sure the remake is good too, though-both are on Steam)
Silent Hill 2
Song of Horror Complete Edition
Tormented Souls
White Day: A Labyrinth Named School
Withering Rooms

If you’re wanting more low-poly horror games (similar visual style to Puppet Combo games):
Alisa
Dead End Road
No One Lives Under the Lighthouse

If you want games with a spooky/Halloween vibe, but not exactly horror (of various other genres):
Afterparty
Cabernet
Cult of the Lamb
Desvelado
Dredge
Fran Bow
Graveyard Keeper
Oxenfree
The Path
Pumpkin Jack
Pumpkin Panic (free)
V Rising
Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodhunt (free)

on steam:

- fear & hunger 1 and 2
- look outside
- omori
- tormented souls 1 and 2
- crow country
- signalis
- conscript
- hollowbody
- sorry were closed
- darkwood
- lisa the painful
- withering rooms
- Ib
- mad father
- witchs house
- corpse party series
- milk inside a bag of milk inside a bag of milk
- milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk
- resident evil 1, 2, 3, and 4 remakes
- resident evil 0
- resident evil 7 and 8
- silent hill 2 remake
- silent hill f
- splitterhead
- mouthwashing
- condemned
- FEAR
- fatal frame 4 and 5 (kraken reminded me 5 is on steam)
- manhunt
- outlast 1 and 2
- detention
- lost in vivo
- alisa
- cry of fear
- vampire the masquerade bloodlines
- penumbra trilogy
- alien isolation
- system shock 2
- call of cthulhu dark corners of the earth
- eye of isis
- bioshock 1 and 2
- castlevania series
- clock tower remake
- deadly premonition 1 and 2
- obscure
- the thing
- doom series
- the evil within 1 and 2
- dead space series
- the last of us 1 and 2
- dead rising series
- soma
- amnesia series
- phantasmagoria
- harvester
- sanitarium
- pathologic 1 and 2

off steam:

- silent hill 1-4
- resident evil 1-3 originals + code veronica
- fatal frame 1-3
- clock tower series
- kuon
- haunting ground
- rule of rose
- eternal darkness sanitys requiem
- bloodborne
- forbidden siren trilogy
- dino crisis 1 and 2
- parasite eve 1 and 2
- galerians 1 and 2
- koudelka and shadow hearts 1 and 2
- echo night trilogy
- the x files resist or serve
- resident evil outbreak 1 and 2
- michigan report from hell
- the suffering
- gregory horror show
- the darkness
- silent hill shattered memories
- illbleed
- blue stinger
- martian gothic
- fear effect 1 and 2
- overblood 1 and 2
- countdown vampires
- alone in the dark series
- condemned 2
- deception series
- chaos break
- castlevania symphony of the night
- clive barkers undying
- clive barkers jericho

Wow those are more games than I expected. I will go through literally all of them so thank you so much for the recommendations!

Two Point Museum has a Vampire Survivors crossover for halloween.

I should also mention the "too spooky 4 me" game: Alien: Isolation. Just in case you haven't played it.

Originally posted by salamander:

-snip-

Nice Fear & Hunger, Obscure series, Signalis, Silent Hill f & especially Pathologic mention. Forgot about those. Fantastic mention of the earlier Fatal Frame’s (1 and 3 still haven’t seen the remake treatment), Kouldelka and Shadow Hearts 1 & 2 (though those-like Fear & Hunger-have heavy RPG elements-while lacking the Soulslike difficulty of Fear & Hunger).

Also massive shoutout for Bloodborne, Eternal Darkness, Rule of Rose, and especially Haunting Ground (Clock Tower 3’s pretty good too)-but I personally think-so far at least, Haunting Ground & Fatal Frame/Fatal Frame: Mask of the Lunar Eclipse are my favorite horror games of all time. There’s just something about them that’s special.

For the record, though, Fatal Frame V IS on Steam, and the remake of Fatal Frame II (most people’s favorite, not mine) I go in-between the original and IV constantly-is coming to Steam soon.

Originally posted by ur fav angel <3:

Wow those are more games than I expected. I will go through literally all of them so thank you so much for the recommendations!

You are very welcome. Please do read the reviews on them because both myself and (IMO) salmander mentioned some pretty niche titles that might not be up your alley at all. Some of them have what many now consider “outdated mechanics”-think tank controls & point-and-click movement, etc. Also, some of the titles can be unbelievably harsh to newcomers until you realize what you’re doing/get a handle on the controls (Clock Tower: Rewind, Song of Horror, Tormented Souls, White Day, Withering Rooms, even Desvelado to an extent)

Then there’s the games where being hard is just part of the experience (the Fear & Hunger games, the Pathologic games (particularly the first-the sequel’s basically a more polished and accessible version of the original), and as for Bloodborne…it’s a Souls game…it’s difficult.

itch not steam but this is one of my favs:
https://mrdrnose.itch.io/votv
free too. it's still in pre-alpha but it's still got lots of content

Originally posted by Jazz:

itch not steam but this is one of my favs:
https://mrdrnose.itch.io/votv
free too. it's still in pre-alpha but it's still got lots of content

This game is amazing.

Originally posted by Ben Lubar:

Two Point Museum has a Vampire Survivors crossover for halloween.

Yea i saw that in my news feed too.

https://store.steampowered.com/app/501990/Phantasmagoria/
https://store.steampowered.com/app/245390/I_Have_No_Mouth_and_I_Must_Scream/
https://store.steampowered.com/app/2794770/Clock_Tower_Rewind/
https://store.steampowered.com/app/1098770/The_Crimson_Diamond/
https://store.steampowered.com/app/2310/Quake/
https://store.steampowered.com/app/1010750/Blood_Fresh_Supply/
https://store.steampowered.com/app/482400/System_Shock/
https://store.steampowered.com/app/866570/System_Shock_2_25th_Anniversary_Remaster/
https://store.steampowered.com/app/319510/Five_Nights_at_Freddys/
https://store.steampowered.com/app/2948730/THE_JOY_OF_CREATION/

https://store.steampowered.com/app/3286930/Heretic__Hexen/

I still prefer playing with GzDoom. Also, disappointing that Hexen 2 and Heretic 2 didn't get the same treatment. The Serpent Rider saga is incomplete.