Sabbat of the Witch

Sabbat of the Witch

View Stats:
Who's the best girl?
I'm starting this discussion to share opinions, not to start arguments. But I am curious as to whom everyone thinks is the best girl. To be fair, I played through all 5 routes and based my opinion on many factors, including entertainment value, story, emotional impact, annoyances, etc.

From best to least, I chose Meguru > Nene > Wakana > Tsumugi > Touko.

Meguru hit me the hardest emotionally, with a very likable character and a great story.
Nene was a close second, but her story was a bit sad
Wakana was a breath a fresh air without any drama, but short
Tsumugi was a bit awkward and silly, but had it's good moments
Touko was kind of boring and felt like she was thrown in at the last minute
< >
Showing 1-15 of 25 comments
Icku 1 Apr, 2019 @ 9:38am 
Nene was the best girl, hands down. Best route that was tied directly to the common balanced with a good amount of drama. Then Tsumugi followed closely by Meguru. who was definitely the cutest, although her route was by far the worst one along with Meguru's. I wasn't really interested in Touko or Wakana, but Touko's route was definitely the second best in terms of story.

So my choice is: Best girl - Nene >>>>> Tsumugi >= Meguru > Wakana=Touko
Routes: Nene >>>>> Touko > Wakana > Meguru>=Tsumugi.

It's a shame Tsumugi's route was more about a side character than Tsumugi herself, lul.
Tentacle Grape 1 Apr, 2019 @ 12:42pm 
Meguru hands down.

As someone who's in his 30s, all my age group are only concerned about getting their feelings hurt, they are easily physically hurt, b!+ching about their rights all the time, and that they are old and unattractive, and they'll talk about their meds and maintenance. it's at the point where you'll never want to have anything to do with them. so what if Meguru is young? she's very much attractive, very easy to approach, none of those b!+ching about their rights and feefees, and just overall an easy life to deal with. all things considered, she's a breath of fresh air compared to these b+!ching adults who can't shut up about their rights. you'll understand someday when you reach my age. the point is, even if she's stupid and uneducated I'd very much prefer her over adults any time of the day. heck I would even say the dumber she is, the cuter and more attractive she is.

fun fact: 90% of college educated women initiate divorce. thinking they can "do better" or they could monkey branch to a "higher status male". interestingly as well, this is the age where they start being legal. soooo, yeah.

Which in turn makes Nene my least favorite. once her curse is lifted can you imagine how much lesser sexy time will they have then? all I'm seeing here is the lesser the sexy time, the more nagging and moaning and whining and b!+ching time she will have. you need to do this, you need to do that, it wasn't done right, it took too long, etc. it also doesn't help that I think in chapter 2 or 3 of her after-route their romance is completely transactional. He does X and she does Y, that kind of stuff. don't get me started on that once they get much older, even lesser sexy time and more nagging time will ensue. sorry to say this but their romance is doomed to divorce once they reached their 30s.
Last edited by Tentacle Grape; 1 Apr, 2019 @ 12:47pm
Icku 2 Apr, 2019 @ 12:13pm 
Originally posted by Tentacle Grape:
TL;DR

Nobody here asked you to describe your life, chill out :D. Good attempt at trolling tho, I'll give you that.
Last edited by Icku; 2 Apr, 2019 @ 12:13pm
Tentacle Grape 3 Apr, 2019 @ 12:24am 
Originally posted by Icku:
Originally posted by Tentacle Grape:
TL;DR

Nobody here asked you to describe your life, chill out :D. Good attempt at trolling tho, I'll give you that.

and nobody asked you to read all that.

edit: but since you did... [insert smug face here]
Last edited by Tentacle Grape; 3 Apr, 2019 @ 12:24am
Icku 3 Apr, 2019 @ 8:25am 
Originally posted by Tentacle Grape:
and nobody asked you to read all that.

edit: but since you did... [insert smug face here]

But it was actually quite entertaining, that's why I acknowledged your attempt at trolling :D
Midnight Dark 3 Apr, 2019 @ 1:11pm 
Originally posted by Icku:
Originally posted by Tentacle Grape:
TL;DR

Meguru has the perfect personality and character traits, (Innocent, genuine, sweet, bright, not to mention cute) which is why her type doesn't exist in the real world.
Nene 4 Jun, 2019 @ 4:41pm 
Nene! Of course!
niconiconii 8 Jun, 2019 @ 1:12am 
Meguru for sure :D
Loud and annoying at times, but genuinely sweet and fun to be with
神様ですか? 14 Jun, 2019 @ 11:19pm 
Tsumugi,best waifu material
panzer.tc 3 Jul, 2019 @ 7:10pm 
Nene, there were other girls in this story
JEROOK 8 Jul, 2019 @ 4:44am 
Meguru, ofc
Waldo Ω 29 Jan, 2020 @ 5:37pm 
All of them are cute no doubt but this is my line.

Meguru > Nene > Wakana > Touko > Tsumugi

Meguru is easiest relate to. Loud, energetic and sometimes obnoxius at school. Unsecure and timid when alone(you and her) plus of course there is the cuteness factor.

Nene's story was intresting, but nothing new, I excpected her character to go 180 degrees south when she uses her outit. She gets embarassed way too much, upping her cute side.

Wakana was short enough to be likeable and her character is favourite support.

Touko's route has been used way too much in VNs.

...and Tsumugi is what I excpect from Nene...dual personality or sudden personality change.
Tamamo-no-Bae 29 Jan, 2020 @ 7:48pm 
Meguru hands down! ^^
Ranis 9 Feb, 2020 @ 7:58pm 
Nene without a doubt. Her story, personality and just everything about her make me love her (I'm gonna reconoice that until I started her route I wasn't really into her, damn I even doubted between playing her route o meguru first, but clearly she ended as my favourite)
Chocolatte 28 Dec, 2020 @ 7:19pm 
meguru!!!!!:steamthumbsup::sanobameguru::sanobameguru::sanobameguru:
< >
Showing 1-15 of 25 comments
Per page: 1530 50