If you are to judge my review, have in mind that I am the kind of player that tries to get or gets all the achievements on games I play.

The main reason for the review being negative is exactly the replayability of the game. Most of the achievements are dull and repetitive, they feel like they are made so that people spend more time playing and therefore the game has better/positive stats (?) or something, I don't know.

Even if you don't care about the achievements but just want to 100% or high% the game, you'll have to get to the end game around fourty times, given that there are nine different endings (you don't have to replay from the beginning for all of them with saves in clever spots, but still it sucks).

Higher difficulties aren't really hard, given that the puzzles and paths you take in the game remain the same The only new thing is some more ghosts to see. Sure the main enemy in the game, the Janitor chases and hears you better but that doesn't make the game harder, just makes me hide more and wait longer for him to go away.

The game has five difficulties, they could have changed the puzzle solutions for normal and hard/hell at least (something like Silent Hill does).

The DLCs are literally just overpriced skins. Wow!

Grade: 5/10.
It is a faithful remake/remaster and the graphics are good, but it has few additions and horrible replayability.
Also, it is one of those games with very basic menu options.

A true masterpiece even after 10 years unlike it's second part which is totally ♥♥♥♥ and trash.