Alright, so even though I recommended the first game, I can't recommend Keepers of the Dark. The game is very broken, at least for me. I hadn't even defeated all of the keepers, yet I got the achievement that I defeated all of them. There was one final keeper I had to beat, and to do that I had to get all of the pieces to this gramophone and put it together. I got all three pieces, but it bugged and said I still needed a final piece. As I was walking around the hub area, I literally stumbled into the final boss, beat her, and the credits rolled. After the credits rolled, it put me back into the game, and when I tried to leave the hub world out of the final mirror (the one you're supposed to be able to exit out of after you complete the game) it told me I still wasn't finished.

So not only did a puzzle bug out, the game bugged out and registered that I defeated all keepers, let me fight the final boss (or one of them, still not completely sure it was the final boss), rolled credits, proceeded to not let me complete the game, and then crashed on me. This might not be everyone's experience, but the game completely broke on me. Judging from the very positive reviews, I guess I was just unlucky. I guess I'm just going to play Dreadout 2, and maybe I'll come back to this one and start a new save and try to beat it again. Hopefully it doesn't completely break when I try again...