Clicked on a link to click on a link to click on a link, but I voted! I love both of them separately, but I think the left one is going to have more personality to attract random people.

(You could still do a reversible cover :3)

Link removed. Personally I like the right one

I prefer the right one, they both look good though. The left looks like the usual JRPG fanfare while the right is a little more ambiguous leading to people looking at the back of the case. All depends if you want to throw up a beacon for those JRPG fans or you want to be more subtle and catch other people who would normally ignore such a cartoony case.

right one they look awesome both doe .Personally i would use the left one as the in game main menu picture or as the back pocket picture or anyhing that include it int he game!!

right

right

The right one looks boringly generic. Take the left, it makes the game look fun.

Left for RPG fans and right for casual impulse buys.
I prefer left but I think right would sell better.
If only both styles could be combined.
If I could make one I'd for the right boxart's setup but instead have the view from the monster's angle and have a huge shadow overcast on top of the heroes grouped up and ready to fight, maybe preparing a technique/spell, very mid action and showing character traits and fighting styles a bit.
Leave the enemy a bit to the imagination and looks a bit more menacing.
At first glass a gamer wants to know what the heroes they have to use will be like.
Like how do I know who is and isn't the magic user? Maybe its the cat thing? Maybe the small one is a bigger puncher. I'd be left to common guesses otherwise.
Just my two cents. Still I like the left best, if I knew the characters, I'd love to see them on the box right away. The Right would get stale fast but could pull in less experienced gamers.

left, its all about the characters!

A poll that requires a Facebook login? You couldn't have used surveymonkey or something?

the left one for sure

Left. The one on the right has a green filter on it, the colors look washed out. Left has more color variation and has red, green, blue, and yellow visible. Left is a little too busy, I like the simplicity of right, but as-is left is the better cover.

The left one looks much better

i prefer the rigth one. Yes, que left one habe colors better define. But i think the rigth one its diffrent from othes game covers. Maybe if just turn the letters white

I love the color and whimsical nature of the one on the left, but the one on the right is timeless. Let's go Right;)