A worthy new remaster of the 90s point-and-click classic that sends one of the most likable sociopaths in all of gaming history on a globetrotting adventure to stop a worldwide conspiracy.
The new version keeps closely to the 1996 original script instead of the changes and additions of the 2009 remastered edition. While I personally never minded the 2009 additions as much as many seemed to do, it is mostly in restoring some of the remasters' changes to the original (like the opening speech) that Reforged greatly improves on the remaster. At the same time, some of the visual and UI updates do work rather well, and it offers the option to switch between the Reforged and the original graphics (though UI elements remain in the updated form). All this makes Reforged, in my opinion, the best currently available version of the game.

Pros:
- Great characters with (in the German dub) some of my favorite voice work. The main character is - in best adventure game fashion - a cheerfully unrepentant criminal with lots of charm, personality, and witty dialogue. He is joined by a large cast of often eccentric characters. His main antagonist, an international costumed serial killer/assassin, while only sparingly encountered, is often referenced in descriptions of his exploits by other characters. As he seeks out and procures information and disguises himself, it always seemed to me that he was in his own point-and-click adventure, doing as many shady or downright illegal things as our protagonist. The relationship between the leads generally worked really well, though I always thought that the romantic aspects were ramped up a bit too fast towards the end.
- A truly fun adventure story with a fascinating historical subject matter presented in a way that really stokes your interest and curiosity. Strangely enough, my personal favorite part of the story was always one that went a bit further astray off the main story's path - uncovering the rather melancholic history of the Vasconcellos with their last living descendant. The writing is full of charm and humor.
- The game brings you to varied and memorable locations with great character art and background designs. I also generally really like the graphical updates, especially for the characters, though it sometimes seemed like some designs of minor characters became a little less grotesque, a little less distinctive. Similarly, I mostly liked the new background art with few exceptions. Most changes in the environments will likely come down to a matter of taste. The one area that I felt was a clear downgrade was the Villa de Vasconcellos and its gardens, which seemed much cleaner and orderly in the Reforged version, which, to me, took some of the charm away. Though this may just be because of how much I liked this location and its atmosphere back in the day. Still, especially with the ability to seamlessly switch between old and new graphics, it was a delight to see the old story and characters in a faithful new look.
- It is hard to rate the difficulty and intuitiveness of puzzles when one remembers at least the more memorable ones from years ago. By and large they are more grounded and seemed more or less logical to me. The difficulty overall tends towards the lower end - so it mostly keeps the story moving. There is a story mode option and a hint system available, though I cannot rate their usefulness.
- The UI is generally kept simple and decently intuitive; my biggest problem in the Reforged edition was with a few of the "come hither" movements in bigger scenes. The dialogue interface, which offers some preselected topics (that may need to be unlocked through other actions) and inventory items, keeps the storyline running without getting too bogged down in a myriad of options.
- Together with some wonderful music, all these points create a wonderfully engrossing atmosphere and a fun gameplay experience.

Cons:
- There are some parts of the story that do not flow quite as nicely as they could. Especially the Neo-Templars as the final antagonists could have been more developed. I also think that if you seem to outpace them at every clue that leads towards the endgame location, then there should be a better explanation for why they actually beat our hero to that place.
- As great as music, envionmental sounds and voice work are, there were some clear audio quality and mixing issues.
- At the time of my playthrough, there were still a few minor bugs in the Reforged edition, like the ability to enter the boarded-up café, which led to George changing size as he walked inside the shuttered windows. These problems may have been patched out since then.

A fantastic and faithful remaster of the original game. It brought back a flood of warm nostalgia, but even without the nostalgia glasses, Revolution has done an excellent job. I'm thoroughly excited to finish this, replay the others in the series, and look forward to Parzival's Stone!

An absolute classic, re-imagined with updated graphics and a built-in (but optional) hint system, so you wont get stuck on the castle goat puzzle for 2 years like I did playing the original! 10/10

As a kid, I had pirated this game. And now I can repay the debt.
When growing up, Broken Sword had a huge impact on me. I even wrote an essay to school about the Templars.
Thank you Revolution Software!

Oh and this remaster is stellar, everything I had wished for.

Best remake ever, it looks so good, perfect nostalgia trip, now do Broken Sword 2 please !

The game looks and plays exactly like we remember it.
A timeless classic.

Played the original release 27 years ago and have pretty much forgotten everything about this game over the years.
Now with the Reforged version it was time to come back and re-experience the game once more. It's good. Very mature, not as funny as some of the Lucas Arts Point'n'Click-Adventures, but the story is interesting and nearly all solutions are logical and don't require trial and error if you think a little.
You can use a built-in help system without penalties if you think you are stuck and it's a nice feature.
Overall a good experience which will take you around 10 hours to complete.

just as good as the first time i played it. amazing game

One of my favourite games growing up. Beautifully recreated with all its atmosphere and charm.
Looking forward to the next game in the series.

The same nice game with a very good graphical overhaul. Interface is somewhat cleaner as well. Some textures very obviously look scaled up and some can be very smoothed over and blurry. But you only notice those because the rest is very well made. Not sure about the voice files in different game languages, they could still be the same.