I would give this game an average rating on it's overall performance. There are many areas that could be improved upon. I have not had a chance to rate its replayability yet either. I have enjoyed playing the game, and I have 17 hours invested in playing. There have been a number of crashes so stability is an issue. It has some nice mechanics like the random events that pop up and the diplomacy is interesting if simple. That is the main appeal and drawback at the same time. It is a simple game that can be learned and played quickly, but there are many times when I found myself wanting more. The units are tiny and very cartoony, but that does add a bit of charm to the game. I really do like the 2d art such as unit cards and leader portraits. Overall as I stated earlier I would say that this is an average gaming experience. Certainly nowhere near the depth of Total War or Crusader Kings. But you can win a campaign in a short time, so there is that. I would say that I got my $19.99 worth of enjoyment from the game. I wouldn't pay more than that in its current form.