If you enjoyed the old Sea Dogs games or Pirates of the Caribbean on the OG Xbox this is basically that but modernized (somewhat). My guess is if you played those older games you aren't going to care that the graphics aren't top-notch. Gameplay is good and perfect balance of depth/progression/freedom. A little buggy but devs are clearly still working to make it better. Absolutely worth the money, especially on sale.

ITS TOTALLY WASTE OF TIME AND CRAP.

Child me could never play this game past being a pirate on a small ship. Adult me hasn't changed that much, aside from reading the quest.